Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Assesses diagnostic measures of order-sensitivity in music and motion, implying crossover relevance.
We report the discovery and repair of a silent normalization bug inWCM-PL v1.9 (`greedy_descent_sensor()` ignored its own `norm_method`argument), and the subsequent design of two new domain-generaldiagnostics: a block-preserving shuffle null (PL-27) and a fixed-dimension,variable-delay multiscale embedding scan (PL-28). We apply these tools toa 36-piece music corpus (Western classical, American pop standards,Italian orchestral pop, Japanese traditional folk song, jazz) and tohuman motion-capture data (5 everyday actions, 120 Hz marker data), usingthree independently derived audio features (spectral centroid, spectralflux, RMS loudness) and two normalization methods (rank, robust) chosenin advance to avoid the minmax-normalization artifacts that haverecurred throughout the WCM-PL project. We find that real music isreliably distinguishable from white noise by whether local structuresurvives block-shuffling out to a ~1.4 s scale (35-36 of 36 pieces,depending on feature), while human body motion -- periodic andnon-periodic alike -- collapses to noise-indistinguishable by ~1 s. Asingle exception in the music corpus, Kreisler's *Liebesleid*, mirrorsthis collapse and is traced (not merely asserted) to genuine,scale-specific loss of order-dependence rather than an artifact. Weinterpret the shared collapse-scale mechanism as evidence that thediagnostic measures repetitiveness/periodicity versus developing,non-repeating structure -- a property that transfers across domains --rather than "musicality" as originally framed. Three follow-oninvestigations (a genre-based rubato proxy, an instrumentationcorrelation, and a same-piece two-performer comparison) each returnedhonest null or confounded results, which we report in full rather thanomit. We close with a self-audit (Section 7) that keeps themethodological contribution (PL-27/28) at NUMERICAL-to-STRUCTURAL andthe music-specific claims at UNDETERMINED, consistent with WCM-PL'spractice of publishing negative and partial results alongside positiveones. ※ The License for the programing codes is AGPL-3.0-or-later.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Watabe et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: