Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Compares mechanical solute dispersion methods in packed bed reactors, suggesting PNM underpredicts dispersion.
Packed beds are a versatile workhorse in chemical industry. In this study, Pore Network Model (PNM) and Particle-Resolved Computational Fluid Dynamics (PR-CFD) are employed to simulate purely mechanical solute dispersion, i.e. excluding diffusion, in such packed bed reactors. Our study assesses the changes in flow patterns and mixing effects for these two methods, by examining various geometric configurations (the ratio of the column diameter to particle diameter is 4.2, 5.25, and 7). The PNM shows to match best with the PR-CFD results for the most homogeneous packing, i.e. the largest column-to-particle diameter ratio. While the PNM on pore-level produces good results, it cannot capture all local phenomena, such as Taylor or boundary-layer dispersion, resulting in an underprediction of the dispersion. • Hydrodynamic dispersion in slender packed beds using CFD and Pore Network Model. • Comparison of throat flow rates, pore-level concentration fields, and breakthrough curves. • Throat and pore-level comparison show a reasonable match between both methods. • Pore Network Model underpredicts dispersion due to neglect of local flow profiles. • Accuracy of Pore Network Model improves with larger column-to-particle diameter ratio.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Claassen et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: