Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A Virtual Issue of Nutrition Bulletin draws together more than 20 papers published in the journal over the past decade that describe, discuss and disseminate work funded under the UK research councils' Diet Research and Industry Club (DRINC). DRINC was first established in 2008 as a £12 million, 5-year partnership led by BBSRC (the Biotechnological and Biosciences Research Council), with funding from three other research councils (ESRC, the Economic and Social Research Council; EPSRC, the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council; and MRC, the Medical Research Council) and a consortium of leading food and drink companies. It was subsequently extended and the final projects funded under the programme are now coming to an end. The aims of DRINC have been to: (i) Support high-quality, innovative, basic research within UK universities and institutes; (ii) Help strengthen and develop the research community in the food area through interdisciplinary research and the provision of training; and (iii) Ensure the transfer of knowledge between the science base and industry through the support of effective networking between the academic groups and companies involved in DRINC. DRINC has now awarded £22 million to 43 research projects from 34 research organisations and, over the course of the programme, more than £2 million has been leveraged directly from food business members of DRINC. Particular features of the way the DRINC programme has been structured are the focus on skills development among early years researchers, as recorded in a paper by Ferriday et al. (2018), recognition of the importance of dissemination to a range of audiences (not just the academic community) and genuine collaboration between university-based researchers and scientists working in the food industry to explore and solve complex food and nutrition challenges that have a bearing on public health, by fine tuning research questions through interdisciplinary exchange and collaboration. The papers collated in this Virtual Issue cover a wide range of topics, as summarised in the second part of this editorial. The DRINC programme is a relatively rare example of a successful public–private research partnership in the diet and health world, epitomising one of the ambitions referenced in the review by OSCHR (The Office for Strategic Coordination of Health Research) (Buttriss, 2018). Through membership of DRINC and attendance at regular dissemination events, scientists working in food businesses had the opportunity to forge research collaborations with leading UK academics in the field of food, nutrition and health. Furthermore, they had the opportunity to feed into the process whereby funding priorities were established and the criteria by which grant applications were judged. DRINC members also had early access to outputs of projects under the programme. Strategic oversight and decisions on the priorities for each funding call and on which grant applications received funding were made by a Steering Group, chaired by myself since 2014. The Steering Group comprised a mix of scientists from industry members of DRINC and from UK institutions, with experience reflecting the breadth of diet and health topics pertinent to the Programme. During this time, the day to day running and logistics of DRINC were managed by the Knowledge Transfer Network (KTN). The themes of the first phase of DRINC (DRINC 1) were: designing healthier foods; enhancing cardiovascular health; improving our understanding of gut health and function; nutrition across the life course; and supporting healthier diets. The themes of DRINC 2 were: designing foods to maintain and improve health; understanding the relationship between food processing and nutrition; and understanding food choice and eating behaviour to improve health through diet. The breadth of these themes, identified by the Steering Group, encouraged interdisciplinary working to tackle complex food-related problems. A particular legacy of the DRINC programme is the diet and health research community that developed and has prospered as a result of the trust developed by working together in a ‘safe space’ and via the many dissemination events and associated networking activity supported by the Programme, which encouraged delegates to mingle and learn from one another, regardless of whether they were at the very beginning of their research career or already well established, internationally recognised scientists. These 2-day events were held every 9 months in different parts of the UK. Early career scientists were given the opportunity to present their work via posters and talks, gaining confidence in the supportive ‘club’ environment. The events also routinely featured updates from BBSRC on future research funding opportunities. Early career scientist Dr Myriam Grundy, now a research scientist at INRAE, the French National Research Institute for Agriculture, Food and Environment, reflected that ‘The DRINC funding programme was a great opportunity; a stepping stone in my career in research. I would not be in my current role if it were not for the skills and competencies (sound scientific knowledge but also the possibility to build a professional network) that this scheme permitted me to obtain. It prepared me to face the challenges we are meeting regularly in our profession’. Dr Charlotte Mills, now Hugh Sinclair Lecturer in Nutritional Sciences at Reading University, added: “Where to start? I can undoubtedly say that being part of DRINC has had a positive impact on my career. The initiative provided me with a platform for interaction between my peers and more experienced researchers as well as the food industry; all of these relationships have been uniquely beneficial to support my career in academia. The regular dissemination events were particularly valuable. Over time, they felt more like family reunions than work events. They provided the opportunity to follow the progress of current DRINC-funded projects, as well as to discuss future research ideas. This ‘safe space’ really built my confidence in discussing my research and generating research ideas.” The importance of DRINC is also recognised by academics with long-standing careers. Professor Ian Givens, a Principal Investigator (PI) from Reading University, responded that ‘my recollection of DRINC was that it not only developed a community of researchers at different career stages, but this was combined with a community of companies. The result was that everyone learned a lot from each other in a non-competitive environment that would not have been otherwise possible. It was uniquely valuable’. Another PI, Professor Paul Sharp from King's College London commented that ‘For me the major success of DRINC was establishing academic-industry partnerships to deliver translational research. We are fortunate to have retained many industry links since the end of the DRINC funding programme’. He added that ‘Academic-industry partnerships are now at the core of the new UKRI Diet & Health Open Innovation Research Club funding’ [discussed later], ‘which it is hoped will build on the success of DRINC. This is a new funding model for nutrition research in the UK. It is potentially very exciting, but funding is for a limited period and there is a heavy emphasis on the academic-industry axis. Nutrition is a very broad subject covering Clinical Science, Population and Global Health, as well as basic food and nutrition science. For future sustainability of nutrition research, it will be important that nutrition remains a priority area for funding by bodies such as NIHR (National Institute for Health Research), as well as the MRC and BBSRC’. The UK has a track record of collaborating with researchers in low-income countries to improve local nutrition and increase skills and capacity within research institutes around the world. Professor Sharp commented that: ‘The recent restriction in overseas development funding via the UK's Global Challenges Research Fund has been a major blow for global nutrition and it is hoped that something can be done to restore or replace this scheme’. Impact monitoring and knowledge transfer have been embedded within DRINC from the outset, with outputs such as the DRINC Compendium, a series of reports and case studies, as well as externally published papers and articles. When I took on the role of Chair of the Steering Group, an initiative was introduced whereby grant holders were routinely invited to submit papers to Nutrition Bulletin about their work under the auspices of DRINC, thereby potentially broadening the audience hearing about the important research they were conducting. An early paper in the Nutrition Bulletin series considered whether the two forms of vitamin D present in food – D2 and D3 – are equally effective in raising plasma 25-hydroxyD concentrations (Tripkovic, 2013), and was followed up by a paper confirming they are not (Tripkovic et al., 2017). This work has continued over the past decade and is brought up to date in a recent editorial in Nutrition Bulletin (Buttriss & Lanham-New, 2022). At the other end of the DRINC time-line, a paper in the December 2022 issue of Nutrition Bulletin (Givens, 2022) develops themes discussed in an earlier paper (Givens, 2022) about saturated fat, dairy products and health, and describes the contribution to current understanding, of work funded by DRINC. Projects aligned with the theme of food choice and eating behaviour have focussed on the gut brain axis in relation to sweetness sensing (Stamataki & McLaughlin, 2017), satiety (Yeomans, 2015), appetite control (Rogers et al., 2016) and propionate production in relation to appetite regulation and bodyweight management (Chambers et al., 2015). A paper in the December 2022 issue (Chu et al., 2022) describes a qualitative study that focuses on understanding what consumers notice about food packaging, and why, and which elements might nudge them towards healthier options and smaller portion sizes. A technique called participant driven photo-elicitation (PDPE) was employed alongside in-depth interviews. Over the past couple of decades, polyphenols and other bioactive substances in plants have been a focus of diet and health research, and this is reflected in the outputs of DRINC, with papers on the role of polyphenols in modern nutrition (Williamson, 2017), rethinking paradigms for studying mechanisms of action of plant bioactives (Kay, 2015), interactions between fibre, plant polyphenols and the gut microbiota (Edwards et al., 2017), and the potential effect of sulforaphane in mitigating the progression of osteoarthritis (Davidson et al., 2016). Also in the Virtual Issue is a paper on a novel way of replacing saturated fat in foods through use of phytosterol-based edible oleogels (Matheson et al., 2018). Differences in the resistant starch content and the impact of this on glucose homeostasis is the focus of a paper by Petropoulou et al. (2016), and Robertson et al. (2021) report on the effect of food processing on the resistant starch content and glucose release from potato products. Enhancing mineral bioavailability from cereals is the subject of a paper by Aslam et al. (2018). Two of the papers focus on interesterification of fats, a process than can control the functionality of fats while minimising trans fatty acid formation (Berry et al., 2019; Mills et al., 2017). Finally, there is a contribution on the impact of probiotics on the immune response to influenza vaccine with ageing (Yaqoob, 2017). Each Innovation Hub is expected to: support research and translation activity that will build upon past BBSRC-supported research or research that complements the scope; provide thought leadership and build critical mass in each strategic theme, by convening and catalysing partnerships. The Innovation Hubs will each have a budget to support the delivery of a range of activities that enable academic researchers, businesses and other users of research to collaborate within the strategic remit of the Hub. It is expected that some Hubs will cover areas closer to commercialisation, whereas others may focus on skills and talent development. Hubs are also expected to broker partnerships with businesses, SMEs, Government departments and the Devolved Administrations to leverage further funding and ensure co-design of projects that can be utilised by the sector, and subsequently inform UK policy. Phase 2 will comprise Annual Collaborative research funding competitions (2023–2027), with a UKRI-BBSRC commitment of £3 million over 4 years (circa £750 K per year). The aim here is to bring together research and innovation from across the Hubs and provide an opportunity to focus on multidisciplinary, cross-sector challenges and/or opportunities that will advance research and innovation relevant to the strategic scope of the programme, but which cannot be achieved by a focus on any single area or Hub alone. The successful applicants for the five Innovation Hubs (Phase 1) will be announced in Autumn 2022. Meanwhile, hot off the press is an announcement from BBSRC of a nutrition spotlight mechanism for reserach funding, in the form of a one year pilot commencing in October 2022, on the theme of ‘building stronger biological understanding of the role of nutrition on human health across the lifecourse’ (https://www.ukri.org/news/bbsrc-launches-new-responsive-mode-spotlight-pilot). Such a mechanism has been called for by nutrition researchers for sometime and the Academy of Nutrition Sciences encourages the nutrition science community to rise to the challenge afforded by this opportunity, stressing the importance of interdisciplinary research in the context of BBSRC's 5-year strategy. The Academy also highlights the importance of reciprocal engagement between nutrition scientists and the BBSRC's peer review process for grant applications, including Panel memberships, to ensure the right balance of skills is available to BBSRC (https://www.academynutritionsciences.org.uk/news/the-academy-of-nutrition-sciences-welcomes-the-nutrition-spotlight-mechanism-for-research-funding). This new initiatives are welcomed but time will tell whether they, along with the existing though limited research funding opportunities that have food and nutrition as their primary focus, will be sufficient to provide the necessary financial support and infrastructure needed to ensure that the successes of the DRINC programme can translate into a vibrant, world-leading and sustainable diet and health research community for the UK. The author was previously Chair of the DRINC Steering Group. The author declares no conflict of interest. Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Judith Buttriss (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: