Key result
Drawing-based analysis and Cartesian-coordinate-based analysis yield equivalent results for aggregate astigmatic data, despite minor calculation errors identified in the original publication.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter confirms that drawing-based analysis and Cartesian-coordinate-based analysis provide equivalent results for aggregate astigmatic data.
In the letter on the theoretical validity of aggregate astigmatic data, Sawhney1 indicates good concordance between Cartesian-coordinate-based analysis and drawing-based analysis. Plotting astigmatic vectors one after the other for preoperative and postoperative data designates the end points of the mean surgically induced astigmatism (SIA) vector. This drawing provides the ability to measure both magnitude and direction of mean SIA. Calculation of the mean SIA by Cartesian-coordinate-based analysis was proposed by Holladay and coauthors in 1998.2 The calculated mean SIA called the centroid also has magnitude and direction.2 Sawhney's statement about the equivalence of centroid and drawing-based analysis of mean astigmatism is a good guide for selecting the correct method to obtain aggregate results. We found almost the same results with these 2 methods. However, there are some calculation or printing errors in the letter. Hypothetical case number 3 has astigmatism of 1.00 × 1.80 (diopter [D] × degree) preoperatively and 0.50 × 180 postoperatively. The SIA in case 3 should be 0.50 × 90 instead of 0.50 in Table 1. With this correction, the exact value of the centroid is 0.24 × 98 according to Cartesian-coordinate-based analysis. We performed computerized drawings for the mean astigmatism described by Sawhney to get more sophisticated measurements than the classic way of drawing-based analysis using graph paper and a protractor. Drawing-based analysis brought us to almost the same results as centroid calculation. Although the digital analysis for Sawhney's figure according to scale was similar to our drawing, the magnitude of the mean surgically induced vector was printed as 0.215 D instead of 0.24 D. As a result, both the direction of SIA in case 3 and the magnitude of the centroid value are incorrect in Sawhney's letter. However, the main thesis of the letter, stressing the equivalent results of drawing-based analysis and Cartesian-coordinate-based analysis for aggregate data, was confirmed by our verification.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Eğrilmez et al. (2003) conducted a letter in Astigmatism. Cartesian-coordinate-based analysis vs. Drawing-based analysis was evaluated. Drawing-based analysis and Cartesian-coordinate-based analysis yield equivalent results for aggregate astigmatic data, despite minor calculation errors identified in the original publication.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: