The review highlights that reducing tissue damage (e.g., via laparoscopic surgery) is more effective at attenuating the inflammatory cytokine response and improving recovery than blocking afferent neural stimulation with regional anesthesia.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Laparoscopy may attenuate IL-6 response more than regional anesthesia; hypothesis-generating and requires RCTs before practice change.
The stress response is a term used to encompass the series of metabolic and hormonal changes common to all patients after surgery which leads to widespread changes in organ function [1]. The response evolved to aid survival of an animal in a more primitive environment; fluid retention, together with glucose, lipid and protein mobilization would be essential for an injured animal that was unable to eat or drink until the trauma had healed. These changes are similar to those found in other stress states such as haemorrhage, burns, parturition and exercise. Although the surgical stress response may represent a universally conserved cellular defence mechanism [2], the stress-induced changes in organ function may also be implicated in the development of postoperative complications and delayed recovery. Before considering what effect these changes have on outcome, an understanding of the factors mediating the response is necessary. Afferent neuronal input from the surgical site activates hypothalamopituitary hormonal secretion and the sympathetic nervous system. The important role of somatic afferent fibre activity in initiating the hormonal changes was emphasized by Egdahl [3], but autonomic afferent activity is also of considerable importance. The onset of surgery is associated with the rapid secretion of hormones derived from the anterior and posterior pituitary: β-endorphin, adrenocorticotrophic hormone (ACTH), growth hormone (GH), prolactin and arginine vasopressin (AVP); together with activation of the sympathetic nervous system and the release of norepinephrine and epinephrine. This is closely followed by increases in circulating cortisol, aldosterone and renin values. In the presence of a marked increase in catabolic hormone secretion, there is suppression of the important anabolic hormones, insulin and testosterone [4]. The outstanding feature of the catabolic hormonal response is the failure of normal feedback mechanisms that control secretion. Muscle protein loss is an inevitable part of catabolism after major surgery, and as much as 0.5 kg of lean body mass can be lost per day. The amino acids released from muscle, particularly glutamine and alanine, are used for essential protein synthesis in the liver and gluconeogenesis in the liver and renal cortex. The proteins synthesized are the acute phase proteins such as C-reactive protein (CRP), fibrinogen, α1-anti-trypsin, serum amyloid A, caeruloplasmin and proteins of the complement series. This increase in hepatic protein synthesis is at the expense of the important oncotic protein, albumin. Muscle protein mass is dependent on a balance between synthesis and degradation. In minor surgery, a decrease in the synthetic rate is probably the dominant factor, whereas in major surgery, both a decrease in synthesis and an increase in degradation occur. Catabolic hormones appear to have only a minor role in mediating changes in muscle protein metabolism, although lack of circulating insulin followed by a phase of insulin resistance are also likely to be contributory. Current opinion favours the cytokines as playing the major role in controlling muscle protein turnover. Glutamine, released from muscle during the catabolic phase, has attracted considerable interest as circulating and muscle glutamine values decrease to only half the presurgical concentrations. As glutamine is important as a metabolic fuel for gut enterocytes and lymphocytes, it has been suggested that this decline may have important consequences for lymphocyte function and may contribute to the immunosuppression found after major surgery. The benefits of enteral feeding on the function and integrity of the gut are well known, but there is little evidence to show any significant effects, particularly of parenteral nutrition, on muscle protein loss. A multicentre study of several thousand patients found no clinical improvement after peri-operative parenteral feeding in major surgical procedures, except in patients who were severely malnourished [5]. In elective surgery, in addition to afferent neural stimulation from the surgical site, cytokines are released in response to tissue damage. Cytokines are a heterogeneous group of proteins, variously termed lymphokines, monokines, interleukins (IL1-17), interferons and tumour necrosis factor (TNF-α and -β), which act on cell surface receptors to regulate and modify cell growth, maturation and repair. In addition to their longer term effects, cytokines also mediate several acute effects, such as the inflammatory response. They are produced from activated leukocytes, in particular cells of the macrophage/monocyte series, and also from activated fibroblasts and endothelial cells [6]. Cytokines derived from mononuclear phagocytes mediate non-specific immune responses and some parts of the metabolic response to injury and have local and systemic effects [7]. It is generally accepted that IL-6 is the main cytokine released after routine surgery. Circulating IL-1β and TNF-α values do not change; occasional reports to the contrary may reflect underlying malignancy or chronic infection. Circulating IL-6 is detected 2-4 h after the onset of surgery, suggesting that new protein is synthesized by the macrophage group of cells. The increase in IL-6 concentration is roughly proportional to the severity of the surgery [8]. Surface surgery was associated with only a transient increase in IL-6, whereas major vascular surgery and hip arthroplasty were associated with a large and sustained rise in circulating values. A significant correlation between IL-6 concentrations and the increase in C-reactive protein (CRP) was found, indicating that one of the main functions of IL-6 is the synthesis of acute phase proteins in the liver. Before its structure was clarified, IL-6 had a number of other names, including hepatocyte-stimulating factor, interferon β2, B-cell stimulatory factor and myeloid blood cell differentiation-inducing protein, indicating some of the other important actions of IL-6 on the haematological and immune systems. These include T-cell co-stimulation, B-cell proliferation and differentiation and plasmacyte proliferation [9]. There is increasing evidence that IL-6 can alter pituitary function, confirming the long-held belief that a link exists between the endocrine and immune systems [10]. There are many metabolic, haematological and immunological changes found after surgery that cannot be explained wholly by hormonal activation following afferent neuronal stimulation; these are usually referred to as the acute phase response. Although it is tempting to ascribe all the changes that occur to stimulation by cytokines, other inflammatory mediators such as arachidonic acid metabolites, complement split products, lysosomal enzymes and oxygen free radicals, which are released with cytokines when fibroblasts and endothelial cells are activated, are all likely to play a part. Afferent neuronal stimulation and cytokine release are the two main factors initiating the endocrine and metabolic response to surgery, but a variety of other important variables can amplify the response. Preoperative anxiety, dehydration and starvation all evoke hormonal changes, while pre-operative hypothermia and haemorrhage and postoperative hypoxaemia, pain, infection and immobilization can augment the response. It must be emphasized, however, that, with the exception of severe haemorrhage, none of the above factors can initiate the response per se. Many studies have tried to improve recovery by attempting to attenuate the stress response. But how do we measure recovery? Some studies have looked at postoperative morbidity and sequelae such as cardiopulmonary and infectious complications, but although morbidity may be influenced by the stress response, other variables such as pre-existing disease and nutritional status are important. An inherent problem is that recovery means different things to different people. An anaesthetist may state that recovery has occurred when a patient has regained consciousness and physiological stability is present; a surgeon may claim that a patient has recovered when function has returned or the patient has been discharged from hospital, whereas a patient may consider that recovery has occurred only when they are able to return to work or have the energy to resume their previous lifestyle. Length of hospital stay is the variable most often used to measure recovery, but this is influenced by so many factors that it is of little value [11]. There has been great interest in the development of laparoscopic surgical techniques and, for many intra-abdominal procedures such as cholecystectomy, recovery from surgery is more rapid after a laparoscopic procedure than after conventional laparotomy [12,13]. This view was challenged, however, when a laparoscopic technique was compared with small-incision laparotomy; in this study, the patient decided when to leave hospital [14]. There was no difference in the duration of hospital stay, time taken to return to full employment and time taken to return to full activity. Nevertheless, the consensus is that the use of laparoscopic techniques is associated with a reduction in immunosuppression and risk of infection as well as rapid recovery and early discharge [15]. Investigations of changes in circulating catabolic hormones and IL-6 after cholecystectomy by the two surgical techniques showed similar endocrine changes but a decreased IL-6 response [16,17]. The lower IL-6 response was not surprising because of the decrease in tissue trauma and was associated with a reduced acute phase protein response, diminished postoperative pyrexia and enhanced recovery. However, the similarity of the cortisol and catecholamine changes with the two techniques suggests that the main stimuli to hormonal secretion are visceral and peritoneal afferent activity and not stimuli arising from the abdominal wall. The concept that tissue damage is a key determinant of recovery is supported by studies in which the length of the abdominal incision was varied [18] and the use of even smaller laparoscopic ports [19]. Increased circulating IL-6-values were shown to predict postoperative complications, probably by indicating the severity of the inflammatory response to trauma or disease [20]. Cytokine secretion occurs in response to tissue damage and so is unlikely to be modified by current anaesthetic techniques. Extensive epidural analgesia (T4-S5) for pelvic surgery had no effect on IL-6 changes [21]. High-dose steroids, such as prednisolone 30 mg kg−1 i.v., attenuated IL-6 production, but were associated with impaired wound healing and dehiscences of intestinal anastomoses [22]. The use of large doses of opioid (alfentanil) was found to attenuate the increase in IL-6 transiently [23], but this was not confirmed when a clinical dose of fentanyl was given [24]. Following Kehlet's [25] suggestion that the neuroendocrine changes associated with the stress response are not essential and that obtunding them may be beneficial, extradural analgesia and anaesthesia and high-dose opioids have been used extensively to decrease the response. Occasional reports have found beneficial effects on morbidity and even mortality by obtunding the response [26-28]. Two comprehensive reviews of regional anaesthesia in 1988 and 1995 found only limited improvements in selected surgical procedures [29,30]. This may reflect the inability of regional anaesthesia to provide complete afferent blockade, somatic and autonomic, in sites other than the pelvis, limbs and eye. However, it is more likely that the failure of regional anaesthesia to alter cytokine-mediated changes limits the ability of this technique to enhance recovery. It is a curious twist that our surgical colleagues, with the success of laparascopic surgery, may have shown inadvertently why regional anaesthesia, despite extensive studies, has consistently failed to improve outcome.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Farrar et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: