Key result
An electronic activity monitor showed favorable effect sizes for increasing physical activity and general health compared to a pedometer over 12 weeks.
Why the study?
It is unknown how high-tech electronic activity monitors compare to pedometers for physical activity promotion and cardiovascular disease risk reduction within primary care.
Does an electronic activity monitor improve physical activity and decrease cardiovascular disease risk compared to a pedometer in overweight, sedentary adults aged 55-74?
RCT (n=40)
Does an electronic activity monitor improve physical activity and decrease cardiovascular disease risk compared to a pedometer in overweight, sedentary adults aged 55-74?
This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Background: Brief counseling and self-monitoring with a pedometer are common practice within primary care for physical activity promotion. It is unknown how high-tech electronic activity monitors compare to pedometers within this setting. This study aimed to investigate the outcomes, through effect size estimation, of an electronic activity monitor-based intervention to increase physical activity and decrease cardiovascular disease risk. Method: The pilot randomized controlled trial was pre-registered online at clinicaltrials.gov (NCT02554435). Forty overweight, sedentary participants 55–74 years of age were randomized to wear a pedometer or an electronic activity monitor for 12 weeks. Physical activity was measured objectively for 7 days at baseline and follow-up by a SenseWear monitor and cardiovascular disease risk was estimated by the Framingham risk calculator. Results: Effect sizes for behavioral and health outcomes ranged from small to medium. While these effect sizes were favorable to the intervention group for physical activity (PA) (d = 0.78) and general health (d = 0.39), they were not favorable for measures. Conclusion: The results of this pilot trial show promise for this low-intensity intervention strategy, but large-scale trials are needed to test its efficacy.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Pilot data on activity monitors in primary care are hypothesis-generating; larger trials needed before practice change.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lewis et al. (2020) conducted an RCT in Overweight, sedentary (n=40). Electronic activity monitor vs. Pedometer was evaluated on Physical activity (d = 0.78). An electronic activity monitor showed favorable effect sizes for increasing physical activity and general health compared to a pedometer over 12 weeks.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: