Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The career choices made by medical students and doctors, and the factors influencing these choices, are of perennial interest to medical workforce planners. This is true in times of oversupply of doctors, and in times of undersupply, because some specialities and some locations are always more or less popular than others. Much interest has been focused on factors influencing a choice of career in primary care. As Barbara Starfield has pointed out, countries with a strong primary care system have better health outcomes, fewer unnecessary deaths and lower costs than those with poor primary care.1 There is therefore an incentive for ensuring adequate recruitment into primary care. Interest has also focused on factors influencing recruitment in rural locations as many countries experience difficulties in recruiting doctors to these areas. It is likely that a balance of factors operating before, during and after medical school is involved in any individual career decision. Two papers in this edition of the Journal shed some light on factors operating before and during training. Ward and colleagues followed two cohorts of medical students from one Australian medical school for 14 years and 9 years, respectively, aiming to identify factors that could predict medical career choice and practice location.2 They found that male students who had a father in medicine and who scored highly on Factor G of Form A of the Cattell Sixteen Personality Factor Questionnaire (indicating people who stick to the rules, are conscientious, emotionally disciplined and somewhat staid) were more likely to become specialists. Female students showed a marked preference for general practice. They also found that students who had ever lived in a rural area were more likely to choose to practise in a rural area. It is not surprising that students from a rural background are more likely to choose to work in a rural area. What is a little more surprising is that this was the case regardless of where, and for how long, they had this rural experience. The authors of this study suggest that attempts to recruit students from rural areas can be encouraged in order to address the shortages of doctors in rural Australia. In the second paper, Goldacre and colleagues present the latest in a long series of reports of career choices of doctors in the United Kingdom, starting with those who graduated in 1974. In the present paper, they report on the career choices of doctors who qualified in 1999 and 2000, the factors that influence these choices, and how the choices vary by medical school.3 They found that general practice was chosen by a significantly higher percentage than the national average of graduates from Birmingham, Leeds and Leicester and a lower percentage from Oxford and Cambridge. Four schools showed significant differences in career choices that were consistent among graduates from 1993 to 2000: Oxford and Cambridge graduates showed a low level of choice for general practice and a high level for the medical specialities, and Birmingham graduates showed the reverse. Leicester graduates showed a consistently high level of choice for general practice. The authors suggest a number of possible explanations for these differences between medical schools in their graduates' choice of eventual careers: applicants may select a school based on their understanding of its reputation in particular subjects; schools may select candidates with particular interests or attributes associated with eventual speciality choice; some medical schools may give more emphasis to some specialities in ways that influence their graduates' career choices; individual teachers may exert an influence; and different schools may convey impressions about careers in different specialities in different ways that may influence speciality preference. It is of interest that in the census of UK Departments of General Practice completed by their Heads of Department in 2001, Birmingham had the largest number of Higher Education Funding Council (HEFC) funded senior academic staff in their Department of General Practice (14) and Oxford had the equal smallest number (3).4 This is partly explained by Birmingham being the largest medical school (339 students admitted in each year) and Oxford being the smallest (113 students admitted in each year). However, the amount of HEFC support provided for a department may reflect the emphasis given to that speciality by the medical school or impact on the opportunities for individual teachers to exert an influence on their students' career choices. To address the current and predicted shortages in general practice in the UK, Goldacre and colleagues suggest that differential expansion of medical student intake could take place at schools where general practice is a strong career choice.3 Further research is clearly needed to identify which of the factors suggested by Goldacre and colleagues and other, as yet unidentified factors, impact on graduates' career choices and which of these can be manipulated to influence career choices in a particular direction, bearing in mind that influencing career choices in one direction may have unpredictable and unwanted effects on choices in another direction.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jill Morrison (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: