Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor: Injury in the workplace is a major concern to all businesses. Work-related injuries cost an estimated $140 billion per year in the United States. The breakdown of these total costs is as follows: companies pay $60 billion dollars (42%) in lost productivity or "lost time" of workers, $62 billion dollars (43%) are paid for "lost quality of life" of the injured worker, $17 billion dollars (12%) are spent for emergency care of injuries, and $5 billion dollars (3.5%) are paid for insurance costs.1 Seventy-two percent of injuries cost an average of $500 per injury, and approximately 10% of injuries account for 75% of the total costs of all injuries. The latter 10% of injuries are also associated with the greatest number of lost-time days, surgical events, and long-term disability. It is well-documented that the greatest expense of work injuries is the rate of workdays lost.2 Sherman, Texas, is a community of 40,000 citizens, with a population base of approximately 250,000 citizens who come to Sherman for employment and business from surrounding areas. Several major companies are located in the area, with an employee work force of approximately 5,650 employees. In January 1997, one of the local hospitals recruited an occupational medicine specialist to provide the local companies with injury care and injury prevention services. Prior to that time, injury care had been done primarily by emergency department physicians who visited the local companies to render injury care during scheduled work hours and the traditional after-hours triage services for injury care after-hours. Several of the companies have had occupational health nurses, safety offices, and industrial hygienists available onsite. After the arrival of the occupational medicine physician, onsite delivery of care continued in much the same format during the same daytime hours, with most of the same plant services. After-hours triage of injuries continued to the same continuous-care emergency departments. These changes provided an opportunity to compare and contrast the cost-effectiveness of providing occupational medicine specialty care and the traditional use of community primary care services to the major industries in a small community. The role of the company physician is to provide medical care to injured employees on the company site as well as off-premises. Additionally, because the doctor has an opportunity to evaluate the workplace, the occupational physician's function is to identify hazardous jobs and provide pertinent information about early intervention and prevention with ergonomic and other modifications. Effective implementation of workplace modifications is entirely dependent on support from supervisors and, ultimately, management. The data presented here were collected by each company for the purpose of Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) log record-keeping. The injury rate and lost workdays rate were calculated with denominators that are specified by OSHA and therefore facilitate comparison between industries. The physician did not have access to, nor have any knowledge of, any data collected in previous years. In addition, the physician was not part of data collection during the year presented in this study. In the companies in which occupational medicine practice was not utilized, the injury rate increased or stayed the same during the 1997 period of time compared. The medical care provided during the previous 1996 calendar year was not rendered by an occupational medicine specialist, and the injury rate was uniformly higher. The illustrated results shown in Fig. 1 demonstrate a uniform decrease in injury rate among the employees and companies that offered occupational medicine services. Statistical analysis using Fisher's exact test shows that it is highly unlikely that the observed reduction in injury rate in those companies that used occupational medicine services was caused by chance alone (P = 0.011).Fig. 1: Injury rate comparison for six major Sherman, Texas, companies for 1996 and 1997.Results from the comparison of the lost-workdays rate between companies that chose to use occupational medicine services and those that did not were also statistically significant (P = 0.0476) and unlikely to be caused by chance. As shown in Fig. 2, a drop in lost workday rates was observed in all companies receiving occupational medicine care except for one company. This company was scheduled to close during 1998 and had experienced an increase in requests for referrals and consultations for chronic problems and a corresponding increase in lost workdays. Despite these data from the one company, the Fischer's exact test probability that the overall reduction in lost workdays among the companies receiving occupational medicine care was caused by chance alone was very low and statistically significant (P = 0.047).Fig. 2: Lost-workday rate comparison for six major Sherman, Texas, companies for 1996 and 1997.These cost savings occurred in an employee base of 4,205 employees, which represents approximately 74% of the employee base among the major industries in Sherman. The likelihood that these reductions in injury rate and lost-workday rate occurred by chance is minimal, as is shown by the very low probability statistics. In conclusion, the practice of occupational medicine in these major industries reduced the overall injury rate and lost-workday rate, both causes of major expense to the local companies. One possible explanation for these observed trends is the ergonomic modification of the workplace that was implemented to reduce injuries. Furthermore, there was verbal and written communication between the occupational medicine specialist and company case managers about specific work restrictions to accommodate injured or recovering workers. These practices were helpful and likely resulted in the measurable reduced injury rates to employees and in reduced workers' compensation costs to companies as well.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lilly Ramphal (1999) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: