Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In an 1894 publication, the German philosopher Wilhelm Dilthey wrote that "die Wissenschaft der Pädagogik kan nur beginnen mit der Deskription des Erziehers in seinem Verhältnis zum Zögling" -which roughly translates as "the science of education can only begin with a description of the educator in his relation to the one being educated." 1 In the 1930s, Dilthey's student Hermann Nohl, by then professor of education at the University of Göttingen, would place the educational relation ("Der pädagogische Bezug") at the center of his conception of education, thus making it into one of the key concepts of twentieth century German educational theory. 2 The idea that relations matter in education -and that they matter in a crucial and fundamental way -is difficult to contest.It is difficult to envisage education without relation, and in this regard it may well be true, to quote the title from the book edited by Charles Bingham and Alexander Sidorkin, that there is indeed "no education without relation." 3Yet to say that there is and can be no education without relation is not entirely without risk.At a practical level the risk is that we may try to relate too much, that is, that we may try to get too close to our students -on the assumption, for example, that we need to know as much as possible about our students, about their history, their background, their identity, their feelings, their sense of self, in order to be able to teach them successfully -and therefore leave no space for something educational to happen, for the "event" of education to occur. 4ere we can take inspiration from Anton Makarenko who, precisely for this reason, refused to have any knowledge about the history of the juvenile delinquents he worked with at the Gorky Colony. 5At a theoretical level the risk is that, by focusing too much on the relational dimensions of education, we lose sight of the gaps, the fissures, and the disjunctions, the disconnections, and the strangeness that are part of educational processes and practices as well; and, more importantly, we run the risk of losing sight of the educational significance of these dimensions.While I do not wish to contest, therefore, that there is no education without relation, I wish to add that there is also no education without hesitation.This involves what we might call "practical hesitation" -the subtle moments where we hold back, where we do not want to know, where we leave space for something to happen that is fundamentally beyond our intentions and control -and "theoretical hesitation" -an awareness of the importance of those aspects of educational processes and practices that are "beyond" or "outside" of a common (or perhaps we should say, an all too superficial) understanding of education-as-relation.It is to the latter task that I aim to make a modest contribution by exploring what, in the title of my essay, I refer to as the "limits" of educational relations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gert Biesta (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: