Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Routine postoperative oxygen saturation monitoring is not indicated for healthy pediatric patients, but is recommended for former premature infants after general anesthesia due to increased risk of desaturation.
Since the early work of McClure et al. nearly 50 years ago [1], hemoglobin-O (2) desaturation has been established as a complication of general anesthesia, spinal anesthesia, and sedation with opioid and hypnotic drugs. Subsequent research into the pathogenesis of perioperative desaturation and technologic advances in the detection of arterial desaturation combined to play a substantial role in improving anesthesia safety to its current levels. During this decade, economics motivates research into the nature of perioperative desaturation as well as safety. Arterial desaturation entails increased cost, either as additional therapy, higher acuity of care, or longer hospitalization. To encompass the total cost of hypoxemia, the scope of "perioperative" has been extended to include the first few days after surgery, as well as the time spent in the operating and recovery rooms. Relatively little is known about desaturation that occurs after the recovery room stay. To decrease cost and preserve safety, we need to define the epidemiology of postoperative desaturation, identify its pathogenesis, and characterize its relationship to anesthetic care and outcome. The articles [2,3] in this issue of Anesthesia & Analgesia by Tyler et al. [2] and Krane et al. [3] begin to address these questions in pediatric patients. Previous research in the adult population found a high incidence of desaturation episodes during the postoperative period after the recovery room stay [4-8]. Catley et al. [4] monitored arterial saturation and respiratory patterns after abdominal and orthopedic surgery in middle-aged and elderly adults who received either parenteral opioids or epidural local anesthetic for postoperative analgesia. Pronounced desaturation (<80%) occurred in over 50% of the patients during sleep, and all episodes of desaturation were associated with obstructive apnea. Interestingly, the severity of desaturation and the frequency of obstructive apnea were increased in the parenteral opioid group compared with the epidural local anesthetic group, implicating opioids in the pathogenesis of postoperative arterial desaturation. Subsequent studies [5-8] have corroborated their findings. Episodes of arterial desaturation during the postoperative period have also been reported in patients after epidural opioid administration. Wheatley et al. [6] compared postoperative arterial saturation in patients who received opioids by either the epidural, intravenous (patient-controlled analgesia), or intramuscular route. They observed that the postoperative time spent in a desaturated state was four times greater in the epidural opioid (12%) group than in the intravenous (3%) or intramuscular (3%) group. Taken together, the research in the adult population indicates that desaturation episodes are not uncommon postoperatively, and that opioids and airway obstruction play an important role in the mechanism of the desaturation. An incidental finding of this research was the discovery that arterial desaturation episodes occur normally in many adults during sleep. Frater et al. [5] recorded arterial saturation during the night before surgery as well as the night after surgery. They observed that most adults spent about 5% of the time during normal sleep at an arterial saturation less than 94%, and that episodes of obstructive apnea underlie many of these desaturation events. These results suggest that opioid administration and the accompanying alteration in sleep state during the postoperative period amplify normal nocturnal ventilatory disturbances that cause desaturation episodes [9,10]. Another mechanism contributing to desaturation during the postoperative period is atelectasis. Jones et al. [9] describe atelectasis as developing in two phases. In the early phase, beginning in the operating room, atelectasis results from decreased functional residual capacity, impaired bronchomotor tone, and decreased chestwall muscle and as a consequence of the position of the patient on the operating table, anesthetic drugs, and muscle relaxants. In the late phase, beginning after the recovery room, atelectasis results from episodes of obstructive apnea as a consequence of opioid administration for postoperative pain. The atelectasis the early phase may persist postoperatively for days because of obstructive apnea occurring in the late phase. If pain is not controlled postoperatively, atelectasis may also result from splinting and shallow breathing. In summary, postoperative desaturation in adults arises from the interaction of two mechanisms Figure 1: an abnormality of gas exchange in the lung (atelectasis) and an abnormality in the control of breathing (obstructive apnea).Figure 1: Schematic for the pathogenesis of postoperative arterial desaturation.There is good reason to suspect that these mechanisms are as relevant to pediatric patients as they are to adult patients. In fact, known developmental differences in respiratory mechanics, respiratory control, and oxygen metabolism suggest that infants are at greater risk of postoperative desaturation than adults [11]. Although many differences exist between infants and adults in respiratory mechanics and control, the key differences are the infant's increased chestwall compliance and the infant's less stable central pattern generator for basic breathing rhythmicity [11,12]. The former makes infants highly dependent on chestwall muscle tone to maintain functional residual capacity and prevent atelectasis, and the latter predisposes infants to apneic episodes, as evidenced by periodic breathing in healthy young infants [13,14] and prolonged apnea in former premature infants after anesthesia [15,16]. The infant's increased rate of oxygen consumption further increases the risk of desaturation [11] because, for a given period of apnea, oxygen reserves will be depleted more quickly than in adults. Several aspects of the Krane et al. [3] and Tyler et al. [2] studies merit comment. Both studies were prospective design. Arterial desaturation was detected by pulse oximetry, and preoperative pulse oximetry recordings were compared with postoperative recordings begun after discharge from the recovery room. These recordings were noteworthy in that computerized systems assisted in data collection and analysis. The Krane et al. [3] study enrolled former premature infants scheduled for inguinal hernia repairs. They alo examined the relationship of apnea, as detected by pneumography, to arterial desaturation in a group that received spinal anesthetics or general inhaled anesthetics. The Tyler et al. [2] study enrolled children aged less than 13 yr scheduled for major surgical procedures. They also compared the nature of the desaturation episodes in a group that received either epidural or parenteral opioids postoperatively. In both the Krane et al. [3] and Tyler et al. [2] studies, the preoperative pulse oximetry revealed that, although baseline arterial hemoglobin-O (2) saturation was more than 95%, episodes of desaturation occurred in the majority of infants and children during sleep. Krane et al. [3] observed that one-third of former premature infants had episodes of desaturation to less than 90% and occasionally to 70%. In the Tyler et al. [2] study, episodes of desaturation to less than 90% occurred in over three-fourths of the patients. However, the time spent in the desaturated state (<90%) was less than 5% of the total time monitored, indicating the transient nature of these episodes. Other work [17] has also reported the occurrence of brief episodes of mild to moderate arterial desaturation in pediatric patients during sleep. The postoperative pulse oximetry data of these two studies were different from each other. In Tyler et al.'s [2] study, preoperative and postoperative pulse oximetry data were identical, for both parenteral and epidural opioid groups. There was no change in baseline arterial saturation or in frequency or severity of desaturation events from preoperative to postoperative recordings. All children were judged to have satisfactory postoperative pain relief. In contrast, in Krane et al.'s [3] study, preoperative and postoperative pulse oximetry readings were different for the general anesthesia group and not the spinal anesthesia group. In the former premature infants who received general anesthesia, the severity of the desaturation episodes increased postoperatively. Several lines of evidence suggested that this increase in postoperative desaturation resulted from obstructive apnea that was not present preoperatively, rather than central apnea. First, many desaturation episodes were associated with irregular breathing patterns and lack of airflow. Second, supplemental oxygen did not eliminate the episodic desaturation, consistent with obstructive apnea. In conclusion, the Krane et al. [3] and Tyler et al. [2] work indicates that postoperative episodes of arterial desaturation are not a clinical problem in children receiving epidural or parenteral opioids for pain relief, although moderate to severe postoperative desaturation episodes can be expected in former premature infants after general inhaled anesthetics. These conclusions, however, must be tempered by the small number of patients who were studied, the coexisting diseases that these patients did not have, and the limited variety of surgical procedures and anesthetic techniques that the patients experienced. In addition, the relationship between desaturation episodes and outcome is unclear. For example, in the Tyler et al. [2] study, very few infants less than 6 mo of age were studied, and details about premedication or anesthetics and technique are lacking. The possibility exists that severe desaturation episodes may occur postoperatively in young infants, in children receiving a certain premedication or anesthetic technique, or in children with neurologic or musculoskeletal disease. In the Krane et al. [3] study, operations other than inguinal hernia repair may be associated with severe desaturation, and administration of opioids may alter the nature of the desaturation events. Whether or not the desaturation events described in these studies result in cardiovascular or neurologic sequelae is unknown. Despite the limitations of these studies, it is reasonable to suggest several clinical recommendations. Checking oxygen saturation as a routine, preoperative test in pediatric patients without cardiac, pulmonary, or neuromuscular disease is not indicated; nor is routine monitoring of oxygen saturation after the recovery room. Postoperative oxygen saturation monitoring should be reserved for clinical indications. Opioids can be administered safely to older infants and children by epidural or parenteral routes in doses sufficient to achieve satisfactory postoperative analgesia. In former premature infants, an increase in desaturation episodes should be anticipated postoperatively after general anesthesia, supporting previous recommendations for postoperative monitoring and care [3,15,18]. Finally, occasional episodes of mild to moderate desaturation can be expected postoperatively in pediatric patients. These episodes appear to represent that which occurs normally during sleep.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Carsten Kurth (1995) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: