Why the study?
This study aimed to compare completion rates and reproducibility of myocardial performance index using conventional spectral Doppler versus tissue Doppler in an unselected high-risk third-trimester population.
Does spectral tissue Doppler improve completion rates and reproducibility of fetal myocardial performance index compared to conventional spectral Doppler in high-risk third trimester pregnancies?
Does spectral tissue Doppler improve completion rates and reproducibility of fetal myocardial performance index compared to conventional spectral Doppler in high-risk third trimester pregnancies?
Tissue Doppler provides significantly higher completion rates and better reproducibility for measuring fetal myocardial performance index in the third trimester compared to conventional spectral Doppler, including in obese patients.
Tissue Doppler improves MPI feasibility in high-risk third-trimester pregnancies; supports further validation before routine adoption.
Objective This study aims to compare completion rates and reproducibility of myocardial performance index (MPI) using conventional spectral Doppler versus tissue Doppler in an unselected high-risk third trimester population. Study Design This was a prospective cross-sectional study of high-risk pregnancies at ≥28 + 0 weeks’ gestation. Conventional spectral and tissue Doppler MPI of the left ventricle (LV) and right ventricle (RV) was attempted on all patients. Results Seventy-nine pregnancies were evaluated. LV tissue Doppler MPI was completed more frequently than LV conventional spectral Doppler MPI (63/79, 79.7% vs. 45/79, 55.7%), p-value <0.01. RV tissue Doppler MPI was completed more frequently than RV conventional spectral Doppler MPI (68/79, 86% vs. 42/79, 53.2%), p-value <0.01. In obese subjects (n = 50) LV tissue Doppler MPI was completed more frequently than LV conventional spectral Doppler MPI (37/50, 74% vs. 26/50, 52%), p-value <0.01. RV tissue Doppler MPI was completed more frequently than RV conventional spectral Doppler MPI (40/50, 80% vs. 25/50, 50%), p-value <0.01. intraclass correlation coefficient for all modalities ranged between 0.73 and 0.93, except for LV conventional spectral Doppler intraobserver variability which was 0.22. Conclusion Tissue Doppler had statistically higher completion rates than conventional spectral Doppler, including the obese subgroup, with evidence of strong reproducibility in the third trimester.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Porche et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: