Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This trial was conducted at the University of Wisconsin’s Arlington Agricultural Research Station (GPS: 43.316713, −89.335280), located 3 miles southeast of Arlington, WI, on a silt loam soil in 2022. Two separate plantings were established intended to evaluate efficacy against the first (overwintering) and second generations of the seedcorn maggot (Delia platura) lifecycle, respectively. The first planting was established on 10 May, and the second planting on 10 June. Each planting measured 22 rows (55 ft) wide by 170 ft long, containing 5 replicates of 11 adjacent plots, each 2 rows (5 ft) wide by 30 ft long, with 5 ft of unplanted space along rows separating replicates. Sweet corn seed (Bayer Seminis hybrid SV1339SK) was planted using a 2-row planter equipped with a cone feeder. Each 30 ft row received 60 seeds (2 seeds/ft). Both plantings were timed to align with a predicted adult seedcorn maggot flight, the first (overwintering) generation was expected to begin at 360 growing degree days (GDD, base 39 °F), and the second generation expected at 1,080 GDD, based on a published seedcorn maggot degree-day model. The first planting, on 10 May, coincided with 394 GDD, and the second planting, on 10 June, occurred at 1132 GDD, so both plantings aligned closely with the beginning of the predicted adult flight and maximum seedling risk. All seed was treated with a fungicide package including 42-S Thiram (5 fl oz/cwt), Apron XL (0.32 fl oz/cwt), Dividend Extreme (5 fl oz/cwt), Maxim 4FS (0.08 fl oz/cwt), and Vitavax 34 (3.6 fl oz/cwt). Additionally, each treatment (except treatment 3, the untreated check) received an insecticide product as part of the seed treatment. Once seedlings began emerging and measured approximately 3 inches in height 10 successive stunted/failed seeds or emerged seedlings were dug up from the center portion of the first row of each plot. The number of damaged seedlings and the total number of seedcorn maggot larvae were recorded. Stand counts were recorded in the second row of each plot 1 wk after the damage ratings for the first planting, and simultaneous to the damage ratings in the second planting. Damage ratings were performed on 19 May for the first planting and 24 June for the second planting (9 and 14 days after planting, respectively). Stand counts were taken on 27 May for the first planting and 24 June for the second planting (17 and 14 days after planting, respectively). Data analysis was performed in R version 4.2.2 (R Core Team, 2022). Stand counts are reported as percentage of total seeds planted (120 per 2 rows) and required no transformation. Insect counts were log(x + 1) transformed to satisfy assumptions of normality. Treatment main effects were determined with ANOVA, and means separation letter codes were generated using Tukey’s HSD procedure (α = 0.05, R package “agricolae”). Despite timing our planting dates using a degree-day model, we still experienced fairly low seedcorn maggot pressure. For the first planting, no statistically significant difference in the number of damaged seedlings, the number of larvae present per 10 seedlings, or the percent emergence was observed between any of the treatments (Table 1). However, this planting had a very strong replicate effect on emergence, with the first and second replicate having the worst emergence. However, removing these replicates from the analysis did not improve the statistical results. For the second planting, there was a significant treatment main effect (Table 2, P = 0.025) on the number of damaged seedlings, with the highest counts found in Poncho (Trt 1) and Lumivia (Trt 7). The lowest damage ratings were observed in Cruiser (Trt 2), Fortenza (Trt 5), Reatis (Trt 4), Lumiderm (Trt 6), and the Entrust 80WP formulation (both rates, Trt 10 + 11). Slightly higher damage counts were observed in the Entrust 240SC formulation. However, despite a significant treatment main effect, there were no significant pairwise comparisons (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). Seedling emergence was much stronger in the second planting relative to the first (roughly 80% average emergence vs. 50% emergence in the first planting), and there was no significant difference between replicates.1 First planting evaluation Damaged seedling count reported as number per 10 seeds. SCM larvae count reported as number per 10 seeds. Treatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. Means followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). Second planting evaluation Damaged seedling count reported as number per 10 seeds. SCM larvae count reported as number per 10 seeds. Treatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. Means followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bradford et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: