Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This trial was conducted at the University of Wisconsin’s Hancock Agricultural Research Station (GPS: 44.116734, −89.534720), located 1.1 miles west of Hancock, WI, on a loamy sand soil in 2022. Plots were arranged in a randomized complete block design and measured 4 rows wide by 20 ft long with rows spaced on 3 ft centers. Potato, Solanum tuberosum cv. ‘Snowden’ B-size tubers were hand-planted on 26 April. Seed was placed approximately 12 in. apart along rows. Adjacent plots were separated by 2 unplanted rows and courses were separated by 8 ft tilled alleyways. Plots were maintained according to standard commercial practices including fertilizer, herbicide, and fungicide applications. Treatments selected for this trial include Verimark 1.67 SC (cyantraniliprole), Admire Pro 4.6 SC (imidacloprid), Belay 2.13 SL (clothianidin), Cruiser 5 FS (thiamethoxam), and Platinum 75 SG (thiamethoxam). All products were applied as both a seed treatment and in-furrow spray, except Cruiser (seed only) and Platinum (in-furrow only). Seed treatments were applied the day prior to planting by tumbling seed in a cement mixer and introducing the diluted product using a single-nozzle backpack sprayer (132-ml mix size). In-furrow applications were performed immediately after placing seed in opened furrows using a CO2-pressurized backpack sprayer operating at 30 psi and delivering 9 gal/ac through a single flat-fan nozzle (Tee Jet XR 8002-VS) while traveling at 3.5 ft/s (1-liter mix size). Colorado potato beetle (CPB), Leptinotarsa decemlineata, populations were assessed on 10 randomly selected plants in the center of each plot for the following life stages: adults, egg masses, small larvae (first to second instars), and large larvae (third to fourth instars). CPB counts were performed on 31 May, 6, 14, 21, 27 June, and 5 and 11 July. Second-generation adults emerged in large numbers by 11 July, so the experiment was concluded at that time. Data analysis was performed in R version 4.2.2 (R Core Team 2022). Insect counts were log(x+1) transformed prior to statistical analysis to satisfy assumptions of normality. Defoliation percentages were arcsine square root transformed. Treatment main effects were determined using analysis of variance. Means separation letter codes were generated using Tukey’s HSD procedure (α = 0.05, R package “agricolae”). Considering all treatments were applied once, at plant, and the extended evaluation period (7 dates), we are presenting CPB counts as cumulative counts to better illustrate the longevity and efficacy of each treatment across the first generation. Some differences in early (6 June) adult counts were observed, with generally lower counts in the seed treatment applications versus the in-furrow applications (Table 1, F = 2.63, P = 0.029). On the last evaluation prior to second-generation adult emergence (5 July), the lowest cumulative adult counts were observed in the Verimark seed treatment, Cruiser seed treatment, and Admire Pro in-furrow treatment. Small larvae hatched and began colonizing the plots starting 14 June, though early differences between treatments were not observed until the following week, 21 June (Table 2, F = 7.9, P < 0.0001). Small larvae counts were among the lowest in the Belay (seed and in-furrow), Verimark (in-furrow), and Platinum (in-furrow) treatments. Large larvae were first observed on 21 June, appearing in large numbers by the following week (27 June), with significant differences between treatments noted (Table 3, F = 7.24, P < 0.0001). Both Verimark and Belay applied as either seed or in-furrow treatments performed well against large larvae, with weaker control observed with Admire Pro, Cruiser, and Platinum. CPB adult counts aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). bTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. CPB small larvae counts aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). bTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. CPB large larvae counts aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). bTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. The objective of any first-generation treatment program is to both keep CPB counts under control and minimize the amount of defoliation generated by their feeding. In our trial, defoliation was variable among treatments, with the Verimark seed treatment (13% final defoliation rating) and in-furrow treatment (23% defoliation) performing significantly better than the other treatments (Table 4, F = 3.52, P = 0.0069). Belay (both seed and in-furrow), Platinum (in-furrow), and Cruiser (seed treatment) all had moderate efficacy, with final defoliation ranging from 38% to 55%. Admire Pro did not appear particularly effective in this trial with final first-generation defoliation approximately 80%, suggesting high levels of imidacloprid resistance in the CPB population at the Hancock Research Station. By contrast, the untreated check plots were nearly completely defoliated by 5 July, 2 wk before the conclusion of the trial. This trial shows that systemic efficacy against first generation Colorado potato beetle depends on both the local population’s level of resistance to the active ingredient in the product, and the method of application chosen. Considering the levels of defoliation observed in this trial, commercial context growers will need to pair a systemic treatment with a follow-on foliar program to achieve sufficient control through the first generation, and should remember to rotate insecticide modes of action to prevent the development of insecticide resistance in their local CPB populations.1 Whole-plot defoliation estimates aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). bTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bradford et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: