Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This trial was conducted at the University of Wisconsin’s Arlington Agricultural Research Station, 2.6 miles southeast of Arlington, Wisconsin (GPS: 43.317005, -89.333661) on a silt loam soil in 2022. Prior to transplanting, the field was prepared by conventional tilling on 30 May to a depth of 6–8 inches. A broadcast herbicide was applied 1 June, the day prior to transplanting (Spartan 4F at 9 oz/ac). Cabbage, Brassica oleracea var. capitata cv. ‘Passat’, was transplanted on 2 June on an 18-inch within-row spacing and a 30-inch between-row spacing into an area measuring 300 ft long by 52 rows (130 ft) wide. From within this cabbage planting, a section measuring 120 ft by 24 rows (60 ft) was selected for the present trial. Four replicates of 6 treatment plots were arranged in an RCB design, with plots measuring 2 rows (60 inch) wide by 20 ft long. Plots were separated by one untreated guard row. The experimental plots were surrounded by additional untreated cabbage to encourage colonization of the field and ensure sufficient uniform pest pressure. Treatments selected for this trial included an untreated check (no application), experimental product 1 (“Exp-1,” with and without NuFilm-P added at 0.25% v/v), Entrust 2 SC applied at 4 fl oz/ac, experimental product 2 (“Exp-2,” with Dyne-Amic added at 0.25% v/v), and Brigade 2 EC (with Dyne-Amic added at 0.25% v/v). All treatments were applied as foliar sprays 3 times on a 5- then 7-day reapplication interval (9, 14, and 21 July). Treatments were applied using a CO2-pressurized backpack sprayer equipped with a 6 ft boom, operating at 30 psi and delivering 20 gpa through 4 flat-fan nozzles (Tee Jet XR 8002-VS) spaced 18 inches apart while traveling at 3.5 ft/s. Diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella), imported cabbageworm (Pieris rapae), and cabbage looper (Trichoplusia ni) populations were assessed by nondestructive (early season) or destructive (late-season, after head closure) sampling of 5 cabbage heads per plot and counting the total number of larvae and pupae found for each species. Counts were performed eight times, on 12, 14, 21, and 28 July and on 4, 11, 18, and 25 August. Data analysis was performed in R version 4.2.2 (R Core Team, 2022). Insect counts were log(x+1) transformed prior to statistical analysis to satisfy assumptions of normality. Treatment main effect comparisons were determined using analysis of variance. Mean separation letter codes were generated using Tukey’s HSD procedure (α = 0.05, R package “agricolae”). Due to the long evaluation period, we illustrate cumulative larvae counts rather than individual weekly counts to better represent the season-long performance of treatment programs. Cumulative counts were generated within each plot across dates, and statistical tests were performed on those cumulative counts. Significant differences in cumulative diamondback moth larvae counts among treatments began appearing on 28 July (1 week after final application), with the Brigade treatment significantly outperforming the untreated check, and all treatments numerically better than the untreated check (Table 1). Across the subsequent month and through the conclusion of the evaluation period, the lowest cumulative diamondback moth counts were observed in the Exp-2 treatment, followed by Brigade, then Entrust. Exp-1 performed better than the untreated check, but worse than the other products. By the conclusion of the trial, significantly fewer diamondback moth larvae had been observed in the Exp-2, Brigade, and Entrust plots relative to the untreated check (df = 5, F = 9.08, P = 0.00024). Imported cabbageworm counts did not start substantially accumulating until 4 August, increasing through the conclusion of the trial (25 August; Table 2). The lowest counts were observed in the Brigade and Exp-2 plots, significantly outperforming the untreated check and the other products by the end of the trial (df = 5, F = 16.3, P < 0.0001). Few cabbage looper larvae were observed over the duration of this trial, with none observed in the Entrust, Exp-2, and Brigade treatments, resulting in a statistically significant difference between these three treatments and Exp-1 and the untreated check (df = 5, F = 4.21, P = 0.011; Table 3). Across all 3 lepidopteran pests evaluated in this trial, similar performance trends were observed between treatments, with the best performance achieved with Brigade, Exp-2, and Entrust. Exp-1, with or without added NuFilm-P, was generally numerically better than the untreated check but not significantly better, and did not perform as well as the other 3 products.1 Diamondback moth counts aApplication dates: A = 9 July, B = 14 July, C = 24 July. bMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). cTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. Imported cabbageworm counts aApplication dates: A = 31 May (emergence), B = 9 July, C = 14 July. bMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). cTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. Cabbage looper counts aApplication dates: A = 9 July, B = 14 July, C = 21 July. bMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). cTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bradford et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: