Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This trial was conducted at the University of Wisconsin’s Hancock Agricultural Research Station (GPS: 44.118994, −89.552245), located 1.1 miles west of Hancock, WI, on a loamy sand soil in 2022. Plots were arranged in a randomized complete block design with four replicates and measured 4 rows wide by 20 ft long with rows spaced on 3 ft centers. Potato, Solanum tuberosum cv. ‘Goldrush’ B-size whole tubers were machine planted on 26 April with furrows initially left open for at-plant insecticide applications. Seed was placed approximately 12 in. apart along rows. Adjacent plots were separated by 2 unplanted rows, and courses were separated by 8 ft tilled alleyways. Plots were maintained according to standard commercial practices including fertilizer, herbicide, and fungicide applications. All plots achieved high levels of emergence, and no signs of treatment-related phytotoxicity or reduced plant vigor were observed. This trial included 6 full-season insecticide programs, each designed to rotate modes of action across both first- and second-generation beetle populations. Products used include Calantha (RNAi, “CAL”), Vantacor (chlorantraniliprole, “VAN”), Delegate (spinetoram, “DEL”), Platinum (thiamethoxam, “PLT”), Agri-Mek (abamectin, “AMK”), Elevest (bifenthrin, “ELE”), and Torac (tolfenpyrad, “TOR”) with the Exponent synergist (piperonyl butoxide). Treatments 5 and 6 were late additions to the trial and could only be accommodated as single plots (nonreplicated). Treatments were applied using a CO2-pressurized backpack sprayer equipped with a 6 ft boom, operating at 30 psi and delivering either 9 gal/ac through a single flat-fan nozzle (at-plant treatments) or 20 gal/ac through 4 flat-fan nozzles (Tee Jet XR 8002-VS) spaced 18 in. apart (foliar treatments) while traveling at 3.5 ft./s. See Table 1 for complete treatment details. Treatment details aApplication dates: A = 26 April (planting), B = 15 June, C = 22 June, D = 29 June, E = 13 July, F = 20 July, G = 4 August. Colorado potato beetle (CPB), Leptinotarsa decemlineata, populations were assessed on 10 randomly selected plants in the center of each plot for the following life stages: adults, small larvae (first to second instars), and large larvae (third to fourth instars). CPB counts were performed weekly from 14 June through 23 August (11 total counts). Additionally, whole-plot defoliation estimates (%) were recorded each week. The plots were observed to begin senescing after the 9 August evaluation so data from the 17 August and 23 August counts are omitted from this report. To determine yield and tuber quality, a single 20-ft-long row from each plot was harvested on 22 September. Tubers were graded using an AgRay Vision X-Ray grading machine which generated electronic measurements of tuber size and weight. The second-largest value of a tuber’s dimension in the X, Y, and Z directions was considered its “diameter” and compared against the following USDA classification scheme: A-size tubers are larger than or equal to 1.875 in. diameter, B-size tubers fall between 1.875 and 1.5 in., and C-size tubers fall below 1.5 in. diameter. Data analysis was performed in R version 4.2.2 (R Core Team, 2022). Insect counts were log(x+1) transformed prior to statistical analysis to satisfy assumptions of normality. Defoliation proportions were arcsine square root transformed. Treatment main effect comparisons were determined using analysis of variance. Means separation letter codes were generated using Tukey’s HSD procedure (α = 0.05, R package “agricolae”). CPB adult counts were similar across all treatments for both the first and second generations, with some differences in mean counts but none statistically significant (Table 2). Treatment 4 had among the highest adult counts across the second generation, likely due at least in part to the plot randomization placing several Trt 4 replicates along the north edge of the trial, adjacent to another potato experiment with poor CPB control and substantial spillover later in the season. First-generation small larvae peaked on 27 June, with statistically significant separation between treatments (Table 3, F = 7.87, P = 0.0023). Among the lowest small larvae counts were Platinum/Delegate (Trt 4), Agri-Mek/Torac (Trt 6). Second-generation material applications began on 13 July, well after peak small larvae populations. Large larvae counts peaked through 11 July and 18 July, around the time that second-generation adults began emerging and second-generation foliar applications were initiated (Table 4). Statistically significant separation between treatments was observed on 18 July (F = 5.59, P = 0.0084), with the lowest large larvae counts in Trt 5 (Delegate/Agri-Mek to Elevest/Torac), followed by Trt 6 (Agri-Mek/Torac to Vantacor/Delegate). CPB adult counts aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). bTreatment main effect p-values determined by ANOVA. CPB small larvae counts aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). bTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. CPB large larvae counts aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). bTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. The ultimate objective of this trial was to evaluate the full-season performance of each treatment program, which is best illustrated by defoliation ratings and yield results. As mentioned earlier, 3 of 4 Trt 4 plots were placed along the north edge of the field and experienced a late-season influx of CPB adults from an adjacent trial, which was reflected in this treatment experiencing heavy defoliation pressure through the second generation (57% average final defoliation, Table 5). The second-generation material in Trt 4 (Calantha) may have also struggled against this strong adult pressure, as it is better suited to control larval feeding rather than adult feeding, and a similar trend was seen with Trt 3 (35.5% final defoliation) where Calantha was the second-generation material. Among the best performers in terms of defoliation management were Trt 5 (Delegate/Agri-Mek to Elevest/Torac, 12% final defoliation), Trt 6 (Agri-Mek/Torac to Vantacor/Delegate, 18% final defoliation), Trt 3 (Platinum/Calantha to Vantacor/Delegate, 18.3% final defoliation), and Trt 1 (Calantha/Vantacor to Delegate, 21.3% final defoliation). Total yields (Table 6) closely matched these defoliation ratings, with the highest yields recovered from Trt 1 (493.4 cwt), followed by Trt 3 (490.1 cwt), Trt 5 (486.2 cwt), Trt 6 (473.6 cwt), Trt 2 (459.1 cwt), and last Trt 4 (366.7 cwt).1 Whole-plot defoliation estimates aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). bTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA. Yield results aMeans followed by same letter code(s) are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD, α = 0.05). Yields reported in units of cwt (100 lbs/ac). bTreatment main effect P-values determined by ANOVA.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bradford et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: