Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
INTRODUCTION: Percutaneous nephrostomy (PCN) is a potentially life-saving procedure that can be performed via the Seldinger technique (ST) or the one-step technique (OST). Despite our positive experience with OST, no definite confirmation of the superiority of either technique has been stated yet. The aim of the present study is to investigate the performance of OST and, comparatively, of ST in terms of safety and efficacy for PCN.EVIDENCE ACQUISITION: We systematically reviewed PubMed®, the Cochrane Library®, Google Scholar®, and Europe PMC® for studies evaluating OST or comparing OST vs. ST for PCN placement. Risk of bias was assessed for each study. Comparative meta-analyses were conducted regarding both techniques’ adverse event and success rates, which were challenged against the ACR-SIR-SPR quality thresholds.EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS: Twelve studies were included, comprising 1,716 patients undergoing 2,071 PCNs overall. The meta-analysis yielded non-significant results for total (OR=1.58 [0.60-1.63], P=0.40), major (OR=1.19 [0.38-3.66], P=0.77), and minor (OR=1.10 [0.46-2.65], P=0.83) adverse event rate, and primary success rate (OR=1.89 [0.52-6.95], P=0.34). Both techniques demonstrated variably compliant performance to recent guidelines. Studies were heterogeneous, particularly in hydronephrosis grading, catheter size, and adverse event reporting.CONCLUSIONS: OST could be adopted as an alternative to ST for PCN, particularly in certain circumstances. US-guided OST PCN could potentially boast additional safety, simplicity, and affordability. Further high-quality data are needed for investigating the performance of the two techniques in diverse clinical scenarios.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Villani et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: