Why the study?
Do left atrial strain parameters accurately predict elevated left ventricular filling pressure in patients with atrial fibrillation?
Do left atrial strain parameters accurately predict elevated left ventricular filling pressure in patients with atrial fibrillation?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Left atrial strain parameters show promise for noninvasive estimation of left ventricular filling pressure in atrial fibrillation, though practical challenges like beat-to-beat variability and rhythm-specific cut-offs remain.
Strong interrelation between atrial fibrillation (AF) and heart failure has been recognized for a long time.1, 2 In addition to the closely aligned pathophysiology risk factors between the two,1 atrial structural remodeling caused by long-standing high atrial pressure make the development and progression of AF in heart failure.3 Vice versa, loss of atrial systole impairs left ventricular (LV) filling and decreases cardiac output by up to 25% and irregular, rapid ventricular conduction can lead to LV dysfunction and in some patients, a tachycardia-induced cardiomyopathy in AF.4, 5 Although AF itself causes elevated left atrial (LA) pressure via diminished compliance of the left atrium2 and thus coincidence of AF carries a risk for occurrence of heart failure, not all of the AF patients experience elevation of the LV filling pressure. Therefore, precise assessment of the LV filling pressure is warranted in AF patients as in, or more carefully than in, other cardiovascular pathophysiology. Echocardiographic assessment of the LV filling pressure plays an important role for the noninvasive diagnosis of heart failure in daily practice.6 To date, various parameters have been correlated with invasively measured LV filling pressures, that is, mean pulmonary artery wedge pressure, LV end-diastolic pressure, LV pre-atrial contraction pressure, and mean LA pressure.7 While a certain level of robustness of the echocardiographic assessment of LV filling pressure has been demonstrated in patients in sinus rhythm,7 accurate echocardiographic assessment of LV filling pressure is still challenging in patients with AF. Currently, use of peak systolic tricuspid valve regurgitation velocity, peak acceleration rate of E velocity, isovolumic relaxation time, and E/e′ are recommended for the evaluation of LV filling pressure in AF.7 Nevertheless, precise estimation of LV filling pressure is still challenging.8 These difficulties are caused by some typical pathophysiological characteristics of AF: irregular beat interval, different filling pattern of the left ventricle from sinus rhythm, and enhanced stiffness of the left atrium.1, 2 LA strain is a relatively new parameter to assess LV diastolic function.9 In this decade, associations of LA strain parameters and directory measured LV filling pressures, functional capacity, or remote hospitalization due to heart failure have been reported in various cardiovascular disorders including AF.9-11 In the study conducted by Xu et al., LA strain parameters were collected in 142 AF patients (most of these were non-heart failure) undergoing catheter ablation.12 When elevated LA pressure was defined as mean LA pressure, which was directory measured via trans atrial-septal approach, of ≥15 mmHg, elevated LA pressure was observed in 41 patients. LA reservoir strain (LASr), LA filling index, and LA stiffness index predicted elevated LA pressure with c index of .794–.819. They set different cut-off values for patients with persistent AF and those with paroxysmal AF (i.e., in sinus rhythm at echocardiographic examination) and proposed an algorithm to predict elevated LA pressure. The reason for these different cut-off values will be explained in the following section. LASr expresses how much the LA wall expands during LA reservoir phase (LV systolic phase), setting the reference length at LV end diastole. The degree of LA expansion during LV systole is determined by multiple factors.9 First, end-diastolic LA pressure fall caused by LA relaxation helps forward pulmonary venous flow into the LA with more LA expansion. Second, mitral annulus decent during LV systole longitudinally expands LA wall and helps LA filling. Third, augmented LA chamber stiffness reduces LA wall expansion. Fourth, the mitral regurgitation stretches LA wall in LV systole. Finally, right ventricular forward flow causes blood return from the pulmonary vein. Therefore, LA relaxation, LV longitudinal function, LA stiffness, volume of mitral regurgitation, and right ventricular systolic function mainly determine LASr. Importantly, LA pressure itself does not alter LASr and relation of LA pressure and LASr is indirect one.9 In this regards, combined index of LASr and other hemodynamic parameters might be conceptually more suitable for assessment of LA pressure. LA filling index, calculated as transmitral E velocity over LASr, reflects not only the influence of the pressure gradient between the LA and LV on LV filling but also the relaxation and compliance of the LA affected by LV diastolic function.13 Another index, LA stiffness index (E/e′/LASr), was proposed to express the pressure rise per volume increase by regarding the E/e′ and LASr as LA pressure and volume change, respectively.14 Although this index does not express LA pressure as LASr does not, close interaction between LA stiffness and LA pressure might make them associate each other. What is problematic in using LA strain in AF is that LA strain dramatically reduces in the AF rhythm. Therefore, normal ranges should be set at different values between AF and sinus rhythm. Actually, the cut-off values of LASr indices in Xu study were substantially lower in patients with persistent AF than those in paroxysmal AF.12 Further, LASr should be reduced just after the termination of AF due to LA stunning even when the patient was in sinus rhythm at the time of examination. Therefore, duration from the AF termination might be needed to be taken into account when assessing LA strain in paroxysmal AF patients. In addition, beat to beat variability always affect the accuracy of echocardiographic parameters. Because LA filling index and LA stiffness index are combined indices of two or more parameters, they are vulnerable for variability according to R-R interval. Although Xu study did not clarify how they aligned the variability, use of measurements from multiple heat beats are usually recommended in AF patients.7 This, however, often poses important limitations to routine application of this kind of measurements.7 Another approach to obtain a typical value might be measure the parameters in a beat with similar preceding RR interval and pre-preceding RR interval,15 whereas this approach was not fully assessed in LA strain parameters. Further research is necessary to clarify the utility of LA strain parameters for the assessment of LV filling pressure.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hiroyuki Iwano (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: