Key result
Left atrial reservoir strain provides additive value in diagnosing heart failure with preserved ejection fraction, demonstrating high specificity but relatively low sensitivity.
Why the study?
Does left atrial reservoir strain improve the diagnostic accuracy for HFpEF in patients with unexplained dyspnoea?
Does left atrial reservoir strain improve the diagnostic accuracy for HFpEF in patients with unexplained dyspnoea?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Left atrial reservoir strain improves the diagnostic evaluation of HFpEF, though resting echocardiographic measurements may lack sensitivity compared to exercise stress testing.
This article refers to ‘Left atrial strain and compliance in the diagnostic evaluation of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction’ by Y.N.V. Reddy et al., published in this issue on pages 891–900. Left ventricular diastolic dysfunction (LVDD) is an independent predictor of all-cause mortality in the general population, even in the preclinical stage,1 and evidence of LVDD is required for the diagnosis of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF).2 Despite the fact that cardiac catheterization is the ‘gold standard’ to evaluate left ventricular (LV) diastolic function and LV filling pressures, routine invasive assessment is impractical and, in clinical practice, echocardiography has become the most frequently used diagnostic test to confirm or exclude LVDD in patients with unexplained exertional dyspnoea.3 Given the complexity of LV diastolic function in itself and the many interrelated factors that influence it, no single echocardiographic parameter can be used in isolation to make the diagnosis of LVDD.4 Accordingly, the American Society of Echocardiography and the European Association of Cardiovascular Imaging jointly proposed an integrated algorithm incorporating multiple parameters, which include among other variables e' velocity, E/e' ratio, tricuspid regurgitation peak velocity, and indexed maximal left atrial volume (LAV).4 LAV provides robust information on the chronicity and severity of LVDD, and in patients with LVDD and normal LV filling pressures at rest, increased LAV can predict the increase in LV filling pressure during exercise.5 The advantages of using LAV as a parameter of LVDD relate to its feasibility and reproducibility, and maximal LAV is currently considered superior to other echocardiographic markers, being increasingly used in large randomized clinical trials.6, 7 However, LAV can still be normal in the early phases of grade I LVDD, as the left atrium may take time to remodel, and can also be unreliable in patients in whom heart failure therapy results in normalization of LV filling pressure.8 Despite normal LV diastolic function, LAV can enlarge in patients with bradycardia, high-output states, atrial arrhythmias, significant mitral valve disease, or in trained athletes.4 As the primary function of the left atrium is to modulate LV filling (Figure 1A) with its reservoir, conduit, and contractile functions, it is not surprising that functional changes of the left atrium become evident at the earliest stages of LVDD.9 Moreover, LA function may provide additive value, not only in diagnosing LVDD,10, 11 but also in grading its severity.12, 13 In the early stages, the left atrium may compensate for LV diastolic dysfunction through its booster function, but with prolonged LV dysfunction, LA dilatation and eventually LA mechanical failure may occur.9 Left atrial phasic function can be assessed by volumetric analysis using three-dimensional echocardiography, when all LA phasic volumes can be measured from a single volume trace.14 Volumetric LA phasic function can be obtained by measuring the maximum (at LV end-systole), minimum (at LV end-diastole,) and pre-A (before atrial systole, i.e. before the electrocardiographic P wave) volumes. From these volumes, total (reservoir phase), passive (conduit phase) and active (booster phase) emptying LA volumes and fractions can be derived (Figure 1B). Alternatively, LA phasic function can be obtained by either tissue Doppler imaging or two-dimensional speckle-tracking measurement of longitudinal LA strain and strain rate.15, 16 Two-dimensional speckle-tracking echocardiography provides the following metrics of LA strain: (i) LA strain during the reservoir phase (LASr), measured as the difference of the strain value at mitral valve opening minus ventricular end-diastole (positive value); (ii) LA strain during the conduit phase (LAScd), measured as the difference of the strain value at the onset of atrial contraction minus mitral valve opening (negative value). In patients with atrial fibrillation, LAScd has the same value as LASr, but with a negative sign; and (iii) LA strain during the contraction (or booster) phase, measured only in patients in sinus rhythm, as the difference of the strain value at ventricular end-diastole minus onset of atrial contraction (negative value) (Figure 1C). Left atrial strain globally reflects atrial function, remodelling and distensibility. All these components become progressively more impaired in the setting of chronic LVDD, as in patients with HFpEF.10 Therefore, LA strain represents the cumulative adverse impact of chronically impaired LV relaxation and end-diastolic viscoelastic stiffness on the left atrium, which can result in pulmonary venous hypertension during exercise associated with HFpEF. In this issue of the Journal, Reddy et al.17 reported the diagnostic accuracy of LA strain in patients presenting with unexplained dyspnoea, where the diagnosis of HFpEF was definitively confirmed or refuted using maximal-effort invasive exercise assessment. They showed that LA reservoir strain was highly feasible, and demonstrated net reclassification improvement when LA reservoir strain was added to recommended echocardiographic parameters used to diagnose HFpEF. Further improvement was noted when LA stiffness index was added. This important study confirms and extends previous work about abnormal LA function in patients with HFpEF.12, 13, 18, 19 However, it should be underlined the fact that, in this study, LA reservoir strain showed a very high specificity (94%), but a relatively low sensitivity (56%) for HFpEF diagnosis. These findings should be interpreted by taking the methodology of the study into account. According to current guidelines,4 measurements of LAVs (maximum and minimum), LV mass, e' velocity, and LV global longitudinal strain can be used to diagnose LVDD, but not elevated LV filling pressure, as abnormal values are frequently seen in patients with normal LA pressure.20 The same applies to minor elevations in E/e' ratio (< 14) at rest and LA strain. In this study,17 the reference used to diagnose HFpEF was exercise wedge pressure, and many patients had normal wedge pressure at rest. Despite using exercise to diagnose HFpEF, echocardiographic measurements were obtained only at rest, which likely represents the worst case scenario for the performance of echocardiographic measurements as they would reflect a normal wedge pressure at rest but not necessarily its change with exercise. Aside from LV mass, all other measurements are affected by changes in LV preload, afterload and LV relaxation, which change with exercise.4 Moreover, cardiac catheterization and echocardiographic imaging were not simultaneous with a median delay of 6 days between the two studies, which is suboptimal for the objectives of the study. Further, once the diagnosis of HFpEF is established, it is likely to be followed by a subsequent change in management, be it with blood pressure control or diuretics, which in turn lower wedge pressure and alter echocardiographic indices of LA pressure (e.g. E/e' ratio and LA strain), further impacting on the accuracy of echocardiographic parameters recorded at rest to predict the wedge pressure recorded with exercise. Although measurement of LA reservoir strain may be a useful screening tool,13 the most logical and reasonably supported recommendation is to perform the echocardiographic diastolic stress test to diagnose HFpEF in patients at risk, with unexplained dyspnoea and predicted normal LV filling pressure at rest – a similar strategy to what the authors have done in the catheterization laboratory.4 In conclusion, LA function metrics provide new insights into the contribution of the left atrium to overall cardiovascular performance and to improve our diagnostic capabilities for conditions like LVDD and HFpEF. Moreover, LA geometry and function metrics seem promising to predict prognosis in patients with HpEF and could also represent a therapeutic target of this elusive cardiac condition. However, robust clinical outcome data from large prospective multicentre trials are needed to confirm the incremental diagnostic and prognostic power of LA function metrics over LV function data and conventional echo-Doppler diastolic function assessment. Also needed is the development of age- and sex-adjusted normal reference data on a larger scale using the available standardized criteria of measuring LA strain parameters15 and three-dimensional LA volumes.14 Conflict of interest: none declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Badano et al. (2019) conducted an editorial in Heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF). Left atrial strain assessment was evaluated. Left atrial reservoir strain provides additive value in diagnosing heart failure with preserved ejection fraction, demonstrating high specificity but relatively low sensitivity.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: