Key result
Thermodilution carries a low ~6% risk of diagnostic misclassification in pulmonary hypertension versus direct Fick.
Why the study?
Agreement between thermodilution and direct Fick methods is lower than historically estimated, leaving the influence of cardiac output measurement methods on PH classification poorly explored.
Does cardiac output measurement by thermodilution prevent diagnostic misclassification compared to the direct Fick method in patients with pulmonary hypertension?
Cohort (n=1,142)
Yes
Does cardiac output measurement by thermodilution prevent diagnostic misclassification compared to the direct Fick method in patients with pulmonary hypertension?
Despite lower agreement with direct Fick than historically estimated, thermodilution carries a low overall risk (6.0%) of causing pulmonary hypertension misclassification, supporting its continued use in routine evaluation.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Thermodilution carries low pulmonary hypertension misclassification risk; supports consensus for routine use while leaving open need for prospective validation.
Cardiac output is essential to calculate pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR) and classify pulmonary hypertension (PH). Recent evidence has shown a lower agreement between thermodilution (COTD) and direct Fick (CODF) methods than historically estimated. The influence of the cardiac output measurement method on the classification of PH is poorly explored. We aimed to estimate the risk of diagnostic error when using COTD instead of CODF. We used a previously published mathematical model to consecutive patients diagnosed with PH at three centers in Switzerland. This model allows an individual estimation of the risk of diagnostic error when using COTD instead of CODF and is based on limits of agreement (LoA) between COTD and CODF of 2 L/min (average estimation) and 2.7 L/min (worst case scenario estimation). One thousand one hundred and forty‐two patients with PH were evaluated. The mean risk of diagnostic error using the model with LoA of 2 L/min was 6.0% in the overall population ( n = 1142). The mean risk of diagnostic error was 2.9% among the 712 patients with precapillary PH, 15.0% among the 113 patients with isolated postcapillary PH (IpcPH), 7.2% among the 247 patients with combined post‐ and pre‐capillary PH, and 18.8% among the 70 patients with unclassified PH. The estimated diagnostic error when using COTD instead of CODF was generally low, particularly for patients with precapillary PH. Patients with PVR close to the diagnostic threshold of 2 WU (i.e., between 1 and 3 WU), mostly concerning patients with IpcPH and unclassified PH, exhibited a higher risk of diagnostic error.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Genecand et al. (2025) conducted a cohort in Pulmonary Hypertension (n=1,142). Thermodilution (COTD) vs. Direct Fick method (CODF) was evaluated on Risk of diagnostic error (misclassification) when using COTD instead of CODF. Using thermodilution instead of the direct Fick method to measure cardiac output resulted in a low mean estimated risk of diagnostic error for the classification of pulmonary hypertension.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: