Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
school discipline, third spaces, educational enablers, zero tolerance, social justice Background: As schools work to integrate and identify with social justice values, they confront the challenging arena of school discipline and addressing student behavior. Purpose and Research Objectives: This case study on a small social justice high school in the western United States explores the ways in which a school’s efforts to implement nonpunitive approaches manifests in institutional practices that mirror those of less progressive and more conventional schooling structures. Sample and Research Design: The current research presents an in-depth case study of a school with a social justice emphasis. The emphasis on the creation of Disciplinary Third Spaces is extracted from a larger study on Social Justice Schooling and educational enablers. In-depth interviews were conducted with eight school staff, teachers, and a student. In addition, observational data and institutional documents are analyzed and presented. Results: Disciplinary Third Spaces. The study reveals practices that lead to the institutionalization of out-of-class, in-school spaces to send students when conflict arises. The author categorizes them into the following four : (1) Advisory Referrals, (2) NonSuspensions, (3) The “icebox”, and (4) Tokenizing Staff of Color. The existence and frequent utilization of such spaces mirror that of zero-tolerance schools that philosophically sit in contradiction to social justice schools. Recommendations: The findings underscore the need to integrate and reinforce humanizing approaches to school discipline that reinforce social justice values and student accountability. 1. Disciplinary Third Spaces in a Social Justice High School The emergence of small schools as a blooming phenomenon in the U.S. resulted from a convergence of policy initiatives that quickly gained momentum from backing by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and their efforts to create what they called “miracle schools”. While the idea of “miracle” schools purposed for the empowerment of particular communities is not new or unique to the U.S., the explosion of charter schools and small alternative schools brought back the discussion of overtly themed instruction and educational context to the national discourse. The current project is part of a larger study on an alternative social justice school in the U.S. and the creation and evolution of dynamics that contributed to an educational enabler ethic at the school. The Small Equity School (SES) was developed during a time when increased attention was being given to small alternative equity-oriented schools. Over the past 15 years, the school has operated with a clear intent to address the needs of historically marginalized communities located in the San Francisco Bay Area. Located in a city of just under one million inhabitants, the school district in which SES is situated serves roughly 40,000 students. Many of the city’s more privileged families send their children to private schools, leaving the public school system disproportionately populated with students of color and immigrant families. The city itself is in close proximity to the state of California’s “Silicon Valley” which is an internationally acknowledged hub for technological innovation, venture capitalism, and economic development. In the presence of such opportunity
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Darrick Smith (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: