Key result
The WHO/ISH low information and high information risk prediction models disagreed on cardiovascular disease risk classification for 14.5% of patients in rural India.
Why the study?
Can a simplified point-of-care test using age and systolic blood pressure identify patients in rural India who would benefit from total cholesterol testing for WHO/ISH cardiovascular risk assessment?
Cross-Sectional (n=1,066)
Can a simplified point-of-care test using age and systolic blood pressure identify patients in rural India who would benefit from total cholesterol testing for WHO/ISH cardiovascular risk assessment?
A simple point-of-care algorithm using age and systolic blood pressure can accurately identify patients in rural India who require total cholesterol testing for cardiovascular risk stratification, potentially saving resources in large-scale screening programs.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Model disagreement may cause inconsistent risk stratification in rural India; leaves open outcome validation of either WHO/ISH version.
Cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk in India is currently assessed using the World Health Organization/International Society for Hypertension (WHO/ISH) risk prediction charts since no population-specific models exist. The WHO/ISH risk prediction charts have two versions-one with total cholesterol as a predictor (the high information (HI) model) and the other without (the low information (LI) model). However, information on the WHO/ISH risk prediction charts including guidance on which version to use and when, as well as relative performance of the LI and HI models, is limited. This article aims to, firstly, quantify the relative performance of the LI and HI WHO/ISH risk prediction (for WHO-South East Asian Region D) using data from rural India. Secondly, we propose a pre-screening (simplified) point-of-care (POC) test to identify patients who are likely to benefit from a total cholesterol (TC) test, and subsequently when the LI model is preferential to HI model. Analysis was performed using cross-sectional data from rural Andhra Pradesh collected in 2005 with recorded blood cholesterol measurements (N = 1066). CVD risk was computed using both LI and HI models, and high risk individuals who needed treatment(THR) were subsequently identified based on clinical guidelines. Model development for the POC assessment of a TC test was performed through three machine learning techniques: Support Vector Machine (SVM), Regularised Logistic Regression (RLR), and Random Forests (RF) along with a feature selection process. Disagreement in CVD risk predicted by LI and HI WHO/ISH models was 14.5% (n = 155; p<0.01) overall and comprised 36 clinically relevant THR patients (31% of patients identified as THR by using either model). Using two patient-specific parameters (age, systolic blood pressure), our POC assessment can pre-determine the benefit of TC testing and choose the appropriate risk model (out-of-sample AUCs:RF-0.85,SVM-0.84,RLR:0.82 and maximum sensitivity-98%). The identification of patients benefitting from a TC test for CVD risk stratification can aid planning for resource-allocation and save costs for large-scale screening programmes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Raghu et al. (2015) conducted a cross-sectional in Cardiovascular disease risk (n=1,066). WHO/ISH low information (LI) risk prediction model vs. WHO/ISH high information (HI) risk prediction model was evaluated on Disagreement in CVD risk predicted by LI and HI WHO/ISH models (p=<0.01). The WHO/ISH low information and high information risk prediction models disagreed on cardiovascular disease risk classification for 14.5% of patients in rural India.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: