Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Highlights the discrepancies and methodological challenges in current perioperative care guidelines, advocating for multidisciplinary collaboration and standardized approaches.
The field of perioperative medicine has seen a dramatic rise in clinical guidelines and consensus statements to improve patient care. Although this may be welcomed by busy clinicians lacking the time to interpret individual studies, a number of issues need airing. Several learned societies and individual work groups with multiple authors have produced diverse perspectives on the same body of literature, often with different conclusions. A recent example of discrepancy concerns the major joint replacement guidelines of the Enhanced Recovery after Surgery (ERAS®) Society compared with those of the USA-based Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Safety Program for Improving Surgical Care and Recovery. There are striking variations in the recommendations on preoperative carbohydrate loading, local anaesthetic infiltration, peripheral nerve blocks and neuraxial techniques that raise questions about validity1. The conflicting recommendations in the enhanced recovery guidelines for colorectal procedures from European and US Societies are another example2. Among the potential sources of discrepancy is the lack of a unified methodological strategy3, although recent efforts may stimulate a more standardized, evidence-informed approach4. It is not unusual for there to be a failure to acquire the most up-to-date literature1, despite it being a stated goal of many search strategies. If meta-analyses or systematic reviews are used to provide guidelines then outdated publications not reflective of modern care may be irrelevant for current recommendations1. An over-reliance on ‘expert opinion’ approaches (such as a Delphi process) may limit transparency or lack insights into the rationale such that they become eminence- and not evidence-based. It is not surprising that the efforts it takes to develop guidelines according to stringent criteria require full-time staff with a six-figure cost base, especially where there is a need for updates3. Non-uniform, variable selection of outcomes is one of the major guideline biases that can range from economics (direct costs or length of stay) to outcomes (morbidity or functional recovery). Establishing a hierarchy of importance is beneficial, but is not considered routinely where patient-centred or long-term outcomes are included. There is rarely a discussion about patient-specific factors (such as specific co-morbidities, high-pain responders, specific pharmaceutical agents needing attention in perioperative medicine), limiting the breadth of their utility. Thus, even when a well defined scientific approach is employed there may be challenges to interpretation of the literature. Failing to consider multimodal analgesia regimens (paracetamol, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and regional analgesia) when assessing interventional techniques may hinder and prohibit conclusive guideline development5. On the positive side, the publication of many procedure-specific perioperative care guidelines may be the first step to progress6,7. However, it is useful to remember that they should include an understanding of recovery pathophysiology, appropriate pain management pathway implementation, minimally invasive approaches and organizational aspects7. The first step to guideline success may be collaboration between different expert groups, scientific societies and related organizations to establish a current knowledge state, with defined gaps, deliverables and objectives. Groups should not shy away from refraining to make a recommendation where the related literature lacks maturity or definition. A shared endorsement from the interest groups would provide less confusing and far more accessible guidelines for the neophyte and expert alike. Such collaborative efforts may promote procedure- and patient-specific research to answer questions raised, rather than yet another recommendation based on imperfect or inferred evidence. Perioperative medicine is particularly needed in a world where more operations are performed in elderly patients with significant risks of frailty and co-morbidity8. Consequently, updated procedure- and patient-specific clinical guidelines are important to help the busy clinician apply best practice. Multidisciplinary, national or international collaboration with solid economic support is essential to gather the appropriate literature, acquire the knowledge base within, and assimilate the evidence for sensible, robust guidelines. A permanent infrastructure has been recommended to provide updates3 driven by the most recent research in the perioperative enhanced recovery field9. The authors declare no conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kehlet et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: