Why the study?
Data on the validity of wearable photoplethysmography heart rate measurements are limited and often restricted to one exercise domain or limited intensities.
Do the Polar OH1 and Fitbit Charge 3 wearable devices accurately measure heart rate compared to a criterion chest strap in healthy adults during various exercise intensities?
Do the Polar OH1 and Fitbit Charge 3 wearable devices accurately measure heart rate compared to a criterion chest strap in healthy adults during various exercise intensities?
The Polar OH1 provides valid heart rate measurements across various exercise intensities, whereas the Fitbit Charge 3 is generally inaccurate, especially during cycling and high-intensity sprint exercises.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Limited validity data across activities leaves open wearable PPG reliability for clinical use; broader validation trials needed.
BACKGROUND: Accurate, continuous heart rate measurements are important for health assessment, physical activity, and sporting performance, and the integration of heart rate measurements into wearable devices has extended its accessibility. Although the use of photoplethysmography technology is not new, the available data relating to the validity of measurement are limited, and the range of activities being performed is often restricted to one exercise domain and/or limited intensities. OBJECTIVE: The primary objective of this study was to assess the validity of the Polar OH1 and Fitbit Charge 3 devices for measuring heart rate during rest, light, moderate, vigorous, and sprint-type exercise. METHODS: A total of 20 healthy adults (9 female; height: mean 1.73 [SD 0.1] m; body mass: mean 71.6 [SD 11.0] kg; and age: mean 40 [SD 10] years) volunteered and provided written informed consent to participate in the study consisting of 2 trials. Trial 1 was split into 3 components: 15-minute sedentary activities, 10-minute cycling on a bicycle ergometer, and incremental exercise test to exhaustion on a motorized treadmill (18-42 minutes). Trial 2 was split into 2 components: 4 × 15-second maximal sprints on a cycle ergometer and 4 × 30- to 50-m sprints on a nonmotorized resistance treadmill. Data from the 3 devices were time-aligned, and the validity of Polar OH1 and Fitbit Charge 3 was assessed against Polar H10 (criterion device). Validity was evaluated using the Bland and Altman analysis, Pearson moment correlation coefficient, and mean absolute percentage error. RESULTS: and poor correlation (r=0.8). The mean absolute percentage error for both devices was deemed acceptable (<5%). Polar OH1 performed well across each phase of trial 1; however, validity was worse for trial 2 activities. Fitbit Charge 3 performed well only during rest and nonsprint-based treadmill activities. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with our criterion device, Polar OH1 was accurate at assessing heart rate, but the accuracy of Fitbit Charge 3 was generally poor. Polar OH1 performed worse during trial 2 compared with the activities in trial 1, and the validity of the Fitbit Charge 3 device was particularly poor during our cycling exercises.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Muggeridge et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: