Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Based on a meta-analysis of the largely North American literature, Bamberger, Kluger, and Suchard (1999) found that the effects of job satisfaction and union instrumentality on union commitment are partially mediated by organizational commitment and pro-union attitudes respectively, and that union commitment has an effect on union participation. They also found that pro-union attitudes have a stronger direct effect on union commitment than does union instrumentality. In this note, we test the generalizability of these findings based on a sample of union members from the People's Republic of China (PRC). We test a model based on Bamberger, Kluger, and Suchard (1999) (Figure 1), although we conceptualize participation as union citizenship behavior (UCB). Hypothesized Model: Standardized CoefficientsNote: N= 216. *p < 0.05; **p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001. There are at least two reasons why the largely North American findings may not generalize to China. First, there are institutional differences. Chinese unions have performed a “dual function,” providing employee services and representation and also acting as an agent of management and the state in resolving disputes, maintaining labor discipline, and exhorting workers to higher productivity. They have also been responsible for administering welfare programs. Recently, the state has been keen to emphasize the importance of the unions’ representative function, not least because of the growth in labor disputes and social unrest. However, while the representative function may be becoming more significant, PRC unions still differ from Western unions in the extent to which they perform essentially “managerial” functions. This suggests that both union instrumentality and pro-union attitudes may be less salient than in the West, and that union commitment may be strongly and positively associated with organizational commitment, a “dual loyalty” effect. Second, there are cultural differences. China's traditional collectivism and Communist legacy may serve to emphasize collective solidarity, and lead to a relatively more important role for pro-union attitudes. On the other hand, China's relatively low standard of living may be associated with more pressing extrinsic needs and greater salience for instrumentality. Data were collected in 2002 in a Beijing manufacturing company, producing hi-tech electrical switches and accessories, with 1200 employees. There is a company-based union, affiliated to the All-China Federation of Trade Unions (ACFTU), and unionization is around 95 percent of non-short-term contract employees. We randomly selected 300 employees and asked them to complete questionnaires at home and to return them via a box in the workplace union office. We received 291 responses, a 97-percent response rate. Listwise deletion of missing values reduced this to 216. The questionnaire was developed in English and then translated into Chinese by one author and a research student. Responses were on seven-point scales. Organizational and union commitment were each measured with six items, based on Meyer and Allen (1997), with all items positively worded, and with the latter adjusted to include the union as referent. Union instrumentality was measured with Sverke and Kuruvilla's (1995) “instrumental rationality-based commitment” scale, with one general item, referring to the union's chances of bringing an improvement in “my work situation,” replaced with a more specific item referring to the provision of union membership benefits. General pro-union attitudes refer to attitudes toward unions in general (McShane 1986) and was measured with six items (e.g., “unions are a positive force in this country”). Job satisfaction was measured with three items. Union citizenship behavior was measured using seven items from Skarlicki and Latham (1996), plus four additional items referring to speaking up at meetings, encouraging colleagues to join, reading a union publication and voting in elections. Seven items represented behavior likely to benefit the union as a whole (UCB-organizational), and four items focused on helping fellow members (UCB-individual). We simplified the measurement model by pooling items to provide three indicators per construct (Bandalos and Finney, 2001). Items were chosen at random and averaged, each indicator including between one and three items. Only three items were used for job satisfaction, so pooling was unnecessary. The measurement model, including all seven latent constructs, provided a reasonable fit (χ2= 355.096; df= 168; Goodness-of-fit Index (GFI) = 0.863; Comparative Fit Index (CFI) = 0.954; Root Mean squared error of approximation (RMSEA) = 0.072), with the GFI approaching the 0.9 recommended threshold, and both the CFI and RMSEA meeting their recommended thresholds (>0.9 and <0.08 respectively). All indicators loaded significantly (p < 0.001) on their latent variables. A single-factor model provided a poor fit (χ2= 2039.029; df= 189; GFI = 0.461; CFI = 0.549; RMSEA = 0.213), with a significant deterioration in chi-square relative to the hypothesized model (change in χ2= 1683.933; change in df= 21; p < 0.01). Means, standard deviations, correlations, and alphas are shown in Table 1. Alphas were greater than 0.7. The hypothesized structural model provided a reasonable fit (χ2= 417.456; df= 179; GFI = 0.848; CFI = 0.942; RMSEA = 0.079). The standardized regression coefficients are shown in Figure 1. All hypothesized paths were statistically significant apart from that from job satisfaction to union commitment. All were positive, including that from organizational commitment to union commitment. As in Bamberger, Kluger, and Suchard (1999), the direct effect of pro-union attitudes on union commitment was larger than that of union instrumentality. Our findings suggest that the Bamberger, Kluger, and Suchard (1999) model generalizes to the PRC, providing a reasonable fit, with most of the structural relationships of a similar size to those in their meta-analysis. The two main exceptions were: first, the organizational → union commitment parameter was larger in Bamberger, Kluger, and Suchard (1999) (0.69) than in our analysis (0.182), although in both it was significant and positive, suggesting dual loyalty. (However, when a large Japanese sample was removed from the analysis of Bamberger, Kluger, and Suchard (1999), their union-organizational commitment correlation was reduced.) Second, the job satisfaction → union commitment parameter was significantly negative (−0.57) in Bamberger, Kluger, and Suchard (1999), but nonsignificant (0.026) in our analysis. However, Western literature shows considerable variation in the job satisfaction–union commitment relationship (Fuller and Hester, 1998), so that our result is consistent with Western findings. Our findings provide no support for the view that the dual functioning role of Chinese unions results in union instrumentality and pro-union attitudes being markedly less salient than in previous studies, nor that it subjects members to a stronger “dual loyalty” effect. In addition, the relative importance of pro-union attitudes and instrumentality is similar to the largely North American findings, with pro-union attitudes having the larger direct, and slightly larger indirect, effect on union commitment, suggesting that collectivist considerations are at least as important as private instrumental considerations in developing union commitment and participation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chan et al. (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: