Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Although the great possibilities presented by the study of transmissible tumors of lower animals were fully revealed in 1894 by the systematic observations of Morau, it was not until 1901–2 that the work of Loeb in America and Jensen in Denmark attracted universal attention to this field. Especially in the last decade a great number of observations from a host of workers have produced a body of new data which is of first importance in oncology. From this extensive field it is my purpose to select for discussion certain problems which are of special interest to the general pathologist and to attempt to evaluate the new contributions by the old and established pathological criteria. Prominent among the questions raised by the study of transmissible tumors of lower animals is whether these processes are genuine neoplasms. Considering that Virchow once said that no one even under torture could state exactly what a tumor is, this question must appear somewhat academic. Yet to the older pathologists, thoroughly saturated with the conviction that a neoplasm is viable only in its host, the demonstration of successful transfer to a new host naturally raised a lively scepticism. Transmissibility implied to them infectiousness and a granulomatous nature; the transplantable tumors must be shown to grow solely from the transplanted cells, after the manner of metastatic tumors, they must exhibit infiltrative growth, and produce metastases; the striking morphological resemblance to tumors was not universally regarded as decisive evidence. All these essential attributes of true malignant tumors have now been demonstrated for many of the transplantable growths in lower animals.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
James R. Ewing (1916) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: