Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The article by Quagliarello et al. [1] represents a hoped-for change in approaches to geriatric nursing home—acquired pneumonia, which is largely a phenomenon related to aspiration. The transition from the aspiration event itself to a diagnosed case of pneumonia has been controversial, and the most important risk factors related to the development of pneumonia have been debated. Classic pathogen-related approaches involving a simpler concept of infection and its risks have not revealed all of the important factors involved in nursing home—acquired pneumonia. Patients with nursing home—acquired pneumonia often have multiple comorbidities, and their functional status is very important. The risk of pneumonia is impacted by the intactness of the patient's swallowing mechanisms, the manner in which the patients are fed, the nature of their lung defenses (including cough strength), the nature of their total immune defense, the presence of diabetes, the contents of saliva, the acidity and volume of the aspirated material, and other medical factors. To add dental and oral factors to these many medical factors may seem bewildering, but it was necessary. Quagliarello et al. [1] have used a risk factor and syndrome approach to these cases of nursing home—acquired pneumonia. They have chosen coughing while swallowing and problems with oral cleaning as surrogates for modifiable risk factors. These surrogates are well-chosen in relation to this vulnerable population, if the findings of previous studies are any indication. Previous studies in which I have participated have linked both swallowing problems and oral hygiene—related factors to the occurrence of aspiration pneumonia in a patient population of veterans residing at a nursing home. Two previous studies [2, 3] have demonstrated that the ORs for 2 risk factors—needing help feeding and dental decay score—showed a relationship between these risk factors and pneumonia. The actual OR for needing help feeding was 13.9; for dental decay score, the actual OR was 1.2 times the number of decayed teeth. Other significant risk factors for aspiration pneumonia in these large dental and medical studies [2, 3] included the presence of significant chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, diabetes, high counts for staphylococci in saliva samples, high levels of Porphyromonas gingivalis (a possible marker of periodontal disease), and high levels of Streptococcus sobrinus, a tongue organism that is also associated with poor oral hygiene. An important coauthor in the large, interactive dental and medical studies [2, 3] is Walter Loesche, who has long been interested in the relationship between oral organisms, pneumonia, and heart disease. Other important studies about the relationship between oral organisms, poor dental hygiene, and pneumonia have been completed by Dr. Frank Scannapieco, who with Dr. Joseph Mulotte continues to pursue these questions [4–6]. Although these investigators do not use the same epidemiologic and statistical approaches to geriatric infection as Quagliarello et al. [1], I urge that both approaches to nursing home—acquired pneumonia continue to be used. The approach used in the Yale study [1] may be better suited to evaluating the outcomes of various interventions in very sick and vulnerable geriatric populations. The approach used by the Buffalo investigators [4–6] may reveal important microbiological factors that dentists and oral caregivers will need to know. In the Michigan study [3], we attempted to combine dental, medical, and geriatric approaches. It will be very important to distinguish truly modifiable risk factors in patients with varying levels of functional disability and immunological competence. Coughing while swallowing is an event that happens very often among nursing home patients. It is a marker that signals that such patients need help in feeding, which is the most important risk factor identified in the University of Michigan dental and medical studies [2, 3]. The validity of these obviously related risk factors needs further study, because the approach taken by swallowing and speech therapy personnel in the specific institution is very important and may differ between institutions. It is vital to determine the degree of equivalence between the group of patients identified by their nursing home caregivers as having the risk factor “needs help feeding” and the group identified as having the risk factor “coughs while swallowing.” Many patients are fed too rapidly, and their signal to caregivers is coughing. Others have more problems with their swallowing mechanism itself, and they may cough during a slow, careful swallow under speech therapy supervision. Better methods of quantifying swallowing problems obviously need to be developed, and the tests at present are cumbersome or risky in themselves. Better quality control of feeding techniques and swallowing tests would be valuable. Feeding techniques have been improved by the volunteer feeders taught by Musson et al. [7] in their careful feeding studies. The second major factor identified by Quagliarello et al. [1], inadequate oral care, can mean many things to many people and needs to be measured more carefully. Inadequate oral care was measured in the earlier University of Michigan studies [2, 3] by quantifying the amount of decay and periodontal disease active in the mouth, as well as by recording the number of visits to dental hygienists.Observation of worsened oral disease by a dentist was, in the University of Michigan studies [2, 3], a more direct risk factor for aspiration pneumonia. Whether adequate preventive intervention would consist of simple oral cleaning by mouthwashes, require brushing and periodontal treatment, or require brushing, dental hygiene visits, and a dentist's care remains to be seen. It seems likely that the amount of benefit in preventing pneumonia would vary depending on the rigor of the oral intervention. This repeats the question raised repeatedly in the 1990s and earlier by Limeback [8]. Obviously, an important consideration in the design of a pneumonia prevention strategy is the cost. Quagliarello et al. [1] suggest that a single aggressive oral care intervention may reduce nursing home—acquired pneumonia. But what intervention? Dental intervention can be expensive. Nursing personnel cannot be expected to shoulder this responsibility, because it may include, not only mouthwash, but also gum cleaning, tooth brushing, tongue cleaning, dental hygienist visits, and full dental visits. This crucial question of what dental and oral help the nursing home should offer remains to be answered. The relevant studies of oral agents and their use in nursing home care have begun and are continuing [9, 10]. These questions need to be included in future priorities for investigation; for example, they should be included in lists such as those provided by Muder [11]. It is worth mentioning an oral cleaning intervention—betadine rinses—to which the American consumer is perhaps rather averse. This intervention was tried in nursing homes in Japan by Yoneyama et al. [12] and seemed to reduce the rate of febrile illness. In short, the study by Quagliarello et al. [1] is a worthy beginning to the answer of many questions about effective interventions to prevent pneumonia in nursing home patients. Financial support. Department of Veterans Affairs and the University of Michigan Department of Internal Medicine. Potential conflicts of interest. M.T.: no conflicts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Margaret S. Terpenning (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: