Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviews antibiotic prophylaxis for endocarditis and prosthetic joint infections during dental work, indicating low procedural risk compared to daily oral bacteremia.
IN THEIR PERIODIC updates of recommendations for the prevention of bacterial endocarditis, the American Heart Association (AHA) has simplified antibiotic regimens over the years (e.g., moving from parenteral to oral regimens and from multiple dose regimens to single dose regimens), and some indications for prophylaxis have been removed or made optional (e.g., endoscopy with or without biopsy). The most recent update of the recommendations was published in 1997 [1]. Although the AHA recommendations state that they are “not intended as the standard of care or as a substitute for clinical judgment,” they have become the standard of care in the United States. The best protection from legal action for the practicing physician or dentist is to follow the recommendations of the AHA. To not do so is taking an unacceptable risk. Thus, in answering questions about prophylaxis it is necessary to take the recommendations into account even when they seem excessive, and it is recognized that they are not based on controlled clinical trials. Hopefully, with future updates, the AHA will change more indications to optional and eliminate others entirely. This article addresses some of the common questions that the authors have been asked about prophylaxis of endocarditis and prevention of infections in prosthetic joints in association with traumatic procedures in the oral cavity. The questions and answers apply only to adults. A Cardiologist Asks About the Actual Statistical Risk of a Dental Procedure Producing Endocarditis in a Patient With a Predisposing Cardiac Lesion. Guesses in the literature have ranged from 1 case of endocarditis following 533 tooth extractions in patients with a predisposing cardiac lesion to 1 per 3,000 extractions. However, all estimates have been based on the frequency with which cases of endocarditis have been preceded by a dental procedure. A population-based case control study demonstrated that 25.5% of cases of endocarditis caused by dental flora followed dental procedures within 2 months as compared with 14.2% of matched community controls (without endocarditis), who had dental procedures during a 2 month period (an 11.3% excess of cases) [2,3]. The numbers for less than 1 month (a more likely incubation period) were 13.2% and 7.6%, respectively (an excess of only 5.6%). In this study, 6% of the control population had a known predisposing cardiac lesion. The incidence of endocarditis caused by mouth flora was about 2 cases per year per 100,000 population. However, only 5.6%–11.3% of the cases were likely to have been related to a dental procedure, resulting in 0.12–0.23 cases of endocarditis per 100,000 population. As 14.2% of the control population had dental procedures during a 2-month period, by extrapolation, in a population of 100,000 people, 5,148 (85.8%) of 6,000 with known cardiac lesions would have been exposed to a dental procedure in 1 year. If all cases occurred in patients with known cardiac lesions, there would be a risk of about 1 case per 22,000–43,000 dental procedures in these patients. Considering the fact that only about 50% of those who develop endocarditis on a predisposing lesion have knowledge of the lesion [3,4], and that endocarditis may occur in some without cardiac lesions, the risk in patients with known cardiac lesions is even lower. Despite many potential flaws in the assumptions and extrapolations made from these data, it is obvious that the risk of a single dental procedure producing endocarditis in a predisposed individual must be very low, and that the cumulative risk from activities of daily living such as brushing teeth, flossing, and chewing must be much greater. A Patient Has an Intravascular Pacemaker, Which was Placed 6 Months Ago and is Now Going to Have Teeth Extracted. He Wants to Know if He Needs Prophylaxis Against Endocarditis. There is no evidence to support a relationship between dental procedures and infections of pacemakers. Patients with cardiac pacemakers (intravascular and epicardial) or implanted defibrillators are not at any greater risk than the general population for endocarditis according to the AHA guidelines. According to AHA guidelines other groups not at increased risk include patients who have undergone coronary artery graft bypass surgery or are 6 months post-closure of a ventricular septal defect or patent ductus arteriosus. (6 months was presumably chosen for a septal defect or patent ductus, because by this time endothelialization has occurred). These groups should not receive antimicrobial prophylaxis for dental procedures [1]. A Family Physician has a Patient With a Prosthetic Valve and is Concerned Because His Dentist Did Not Give Prophylaxis for a Filling for Which a Local Anesthetic was Injected Into the Gum, Causing Bleeding. He Wants to Know if the Patient is at Risk Because the Procedure Caused Bleeding. Although the AHA recommends antibiotic prophylaxis for procedures that cause bleeding in the oral cavity, it specifically excludes bleeding from injection of a local anesthetic [1]. The exception is with intraligamentary injection. Bacteria are present in high concentrations in the dental sulcus and it is trauma to this area that is most likely to result in bacteremia with dental procedures [5]. The surface of the gum being penetrated by a needle would present a very low risk for bacteremia. Similarly prophylaxis is clearly not indicated or feasible for bleeding following the minor traumas of brushing or flossing the teeth. An Otolaryngologist is to Perform a Tonsillectomy on a Patient With Aortic Stenosis. He Wants to Know What to do About Prophylaxis Against Endocarditis. Procedures that cause damage to the oropharyngeal mucosa may lead to significant bacteremia. Post-tonsillectomy bacteremia occurs frequently and has been implicated as a risk factor for the development of streptococcal endocarditis [6]. However, there has been recent concern that the microflora and the antimicrobial susceptibility patterns of the organisms in the tonsils of patients undergoing tonsillectomy have changed. A recent study found that 41 of 102 patients (40.1%) were bacteremic after tonsillectomy. Haemophilus influenzae was isolated from 56% of these positive cultures and 25% of these isolates produced beta-lactamases [6]. In 36% of the positive blood cultures, streptococci of the viridans group were isolated and 70% of these had reduced susceptibility to penicillin. Given the high incidence of bacteremia and the low incidence of tonsillectomies performed currently, prophylaxis to prevent endocarditis seems reasonable and is recommended by the AHA in at-risk patients [1]. However, the high rate of H. influenzae isolated from these patients raises the question of whether the prophylactic regimen should contain a beta-lactamase stable antibiotic such as amoxicillin-clavulanic acid or clarithromycin (for the penicillin-allergic patient), rather than a beta-lactamase susceptible penicillin such as amoxicillin. Bronchoscopy is another common medical intervention that may require the administration of antibiotic prophylaxis. Rigid bronchoscopy may cause damage to the oral mucosa, and a third of patients undergoing this procedure develop bacteremia. Endocarditis prophylaxis is recommended in this situation and should be directed against mouth flora. However, evaluation of the respiratory tract using a flexible bronchoscope infrequently results in post-procedure bacteremia. Similarly, procedures where either a transbronchial biopsy or respiratory mucosal brushing is performed rarely leads to bacteremia. Thus, endocarditis prophylaxis is not needed for patients undergoing a flexible bronchoscopy procedure [7]. A Dentist Wants to Know the Best Way To Manage Prophylaxis Against Endocarditis in a 46-Year-Old Female With a Prosthetic Mitral Valve who is Going to Have Multiple Periodontal Procedures Over the Next 2 Weeks. It is clear that administration of antibiotics results in development of resistance of the oral bacterial flora to the agent being given and to related agents [8]. Penicillin-resistant viridans streptococci have been observed in the oral flora as early as 6 hours after starting penicillin and to persist for 9 days after administration of the penicillin. It is likely that there are usually small populations of resistant viridans streptococci present in the oral flora, and with suppression of the sensitive organisms, resistant bacteria multiply to take their place [9]. While it would be best to separate the procedures as much as possible (2 weeks between procedures should be adequate), this is not always feasible. If the timing is less than 2 weeks, it would be best to use a different AHA-recommended class of antibiotic before each procedure [1] and to not repeat the same class until 2 weeks have passed. Amoxicillin, clindamycin, clarithromycin (or azithromycin), and cephalexin (or cefadroxil) represent four different classes of antibiotics that are recommended. As there may be cross-resistance between beta lactam antibiotics, the use of amoxicillin and the cephalosporins should be separated by as many days as possible. A Call From a Patient With Aortic Insufficiency, who was Treated for Endocarditis 1 Year Ago, States That He Just Returned From the Dentist’s Office Where His Teeth Were Cleaned by a Dental Hygienist. The Patient Says That He Forgot to Take Antibiotic Prophylaxis and Wants to Know What to Do. Many patients, physicians and dentists fail to comply with the AHA guidelines [10,11]. Patients may not know (or remember) that they have underlying cardiac valvular pathology or report this condition to their dentist. Physicians and dentists may fail to inform their patients that antibiotic prophylaxis is recommended preceding certain dental procedures or they may even not recognize that certain conditions and dental procedures warrant antibiotic prophylaxis. In a case-control study, the adjusted odds ratio of developing infective endocarditis was 37 times higher in patients with previous episodes of infective endocarditis compared with controls [3]. Thus, the above patient would warrant antibiotic prophylaxis before his professional dental cleaning, a procedure that may provide a potential portal of entry of bacteria into the bloodstream. If antibiotic prophylaxis protects against the development of endocarditis, the mechanism is not clearly known. One possible mechanism is that antibiotics may reduce the incidence and magnitude of bacteremia associated with a dental procedure. Another postulated mechanism is that antimicrobials interfere with bacterial adhesion to platelet-fibrin vegetations. Animal and human studies have both supported and refuted these positions [12]. It has also been postulated that antibiotic prophylaxis actually works by inhibiting and/or killing any bacteria that adhere to and grow on vegetation. In an animal model, antibiotics given up to 2 hours after production of bacteremia were as effective in preventing endocarditis as administering antibiotic prebacteremia [13]. Thus, in situations where unanticipated bleeding occurs or where prophylaxis is inadvertently not given before a procedure, antimicrobials given within 2 hours of the dental procedure should provide effective prophylaxis. After Completing A Course Of Therapy For Infective Endocarditis, A Patient Asks What He Should Do About Personal Dental Hygiene (e.g., Use Of An Oral Irrigator, Vigorous Brushing, Flossing, Etc.). Bacteremias from the mouth are an everyday occurrence. They occur with brushing of the teeth, flossing, irrigation devices, chewing food, etc. [5]. As mentioned previously, in a population based case-control study, only about 6% to 11% of cases of infective endocarditis with oral organisms may have been attributable to a preceding dental procedure. The other cases presumably occurred secondary to bacteremias that are part of the activities of every day living. Cumulatively, these daily events result in bacteremias that are of greater risk for the development of endocarditis than the ones associated with an occasional dental procedure [3,5]. Additionally, studies have shown that the incidence and magnitude of bacteremia is greater in those patients with underlying gingival inflammation [11]. Dental hygiene is felt to be an essential, though underemphasized, means to prevent bacterial endocarditis from mouth flora. Even though bacteremias occur with periodontal hygienic procedures (tooth brushing, oral irrigator, gum stimulator), no association with the development of endocarditis has been documented. In fact, one study suggested that daily flossing was protective against the development of endocarditis [14]. A dental care program will reduce plaque and oral inflammation resulting in a decreased likelihood of gingival bleeding with dental procedures and a reduced incidence and magnitude of bacteremias. Patients who are at risk for developing infective endocarditis should be instructed to maintain the best possible oral hygiene [1]. An Attorney Needs an Opinion on Defending a Dentist Who Did Not Give Antibiotic Prophylaxis to a Patient With Mitral Stenosis and Insufficiency for a Tooth Extraction. The Patient Later Developed Endocarditis. He Wants to Know if the Case Can be Defended and What Key Questions Will Help Make That Determination. When considering the possibility that a case of endocarditis may be related to a dental procedure, there are two questions to be answered. First is the identity of the infecting organism. Staphylococcal endocarditis is highly unlikely to be related to an oral procedure. Staphylococci (especially coagulase positive staphylococci) are rarely isolated from the blood after trauma to oral tissues, and when isolated are in low concentrations [15–17]. The same is true for enterococci and gram-negative enteric bacilli [15]. Endocarditis caused by these organisms is probably related to bacteremia from another site. The second question is the timing of onset of symptoms following the putative causative procedure. If onset of symptoms is more than 4 weeks after the procedure, the endocarditis is more likely unrelated to the procedure [3,5,18]. Even with a more appropriate “incubation” period (e.g., 2 weeks) and an organism of mouth origin (such as a viridans streptococcus), a strong possibility is that the causative bacteremia was from an activity of daily living such as brushing the teeth. However, under these circumstances it becomes difficult to argue that the endocarditis was not related to the procedure. In addition, when an organism highly resistant to amoxicillin is the cause of endocarditis, it can be argued that had prophylaxis been given with the preferred regimen, it probably would have been unsuccessful. An Internist Wants To Know What He Should Do to Determine Which Patients With Suspected or Proven Mitral Valve Prolapse Need Prophylaxis For Dental Procedures. At a minimum, mitral valve prolapse (MVP) is present in 2% of adults [19]. Cost effectiveness analyses have cast doubt on the benefit of prophylaxis for all patients with MVP because of the large number of patients at risk and the relatively low frequency of endocarditis in this group [20]. Furthermore these cost-effectiveness studies did not take into account the cost of echocardiography (if done) in evaluating the patient for indications for prophylaxis [20]. Not all patients with MVP are at equal risk of developing endocardial infection. Certain clinical, epidemiologic, and pathologic features are more highly associated with predisposition to infective endocarditis (IE). The risk of IE in patients with MVP with a murmur has been estimated to be between 4 to 13 times greater than the risk in persons with MVP without a murmur [21]. Limiting prophylaxis to those with a systolic murmur resulted in a favorable risk-benefit and cost-benefit analysis [22]. Infective endocarditis occurs more frequently in men with MVP than in women and in older patients more frequently than in younger ones. Of particular significance, mitral valve prolapse with valvular thickening and redundancy on echocardiography (found in 1.3% of the subjects in an adult population) was present in 94% of patients with MVP that had IE [19,23,24]. Furthermore, patients with MVP with thickening and redundancy of the mitral leaflets are much more likely to have a history of IE [24]. However the actual risk of any one patient with valvular thickening and redundancy developing endocarditis after a dental procedure must be very small. In fact, one authority proposed not recommending prophylaxis for MVP because of the large number of susceptible persons and the relatively low risk of endocarditis from a dental procedure [25]. For comparison purposes, the estimated rates of endocarditis per 100,000 person-years for those with the condition predisposing to endocarditis are: 52 for mitral valve prolapse with regurgitation versus 308–630 for previous valvular surgery and 300–740 for previous endocarditis [26]. The AHA recommends prophylaxis for patients with MVP with valvular regurgitation and/or thickened leaflets. Although the recommendations do not specifically mandate echocardiography in evaluation of patients, it seems highly likely that anyone suspected of having mitral valve prolapse will have echocardiography. As a result, with the present recommendations, the decision not to give prophylaxis will depend on finding no significant insufficiency and no thickening and redundancy of the valves. A Family Physician Asks if His Patients With Orthopedic Prostheses Need Prophylaxis for Dental Procedures to Prevent Infection at the Site of the Prosthesis. One to 5% of indwelling orthopedic prostheses becomes infected. Prosthetic joint infections arise from either local infection (intraoperative contamination or postoperative wound infection) or from hematogenous seeding. The latter accounts for approximately 20–40% of joint infections. Organisms not frequently associated with mouth flora cause the majority of prosthetic joint infections: coagulase-negative staphylococci (22%), Staphylococcus aureus (22%), and gram negative aerobic bacteria (25%). Viridans streptococci and anaerobes account for 9% and 10% of prosthetic joint infections, respectively [27]. Any association between dental procedures and prosthetic joint infections remains unclear. Case series have reported that only 0.04% to 0.2% of patients who received prosthetic joint arthroplasties developed infections that were temporally related to dental procedures and due to organisms found in mouth flora [28]. The actual incidence of prosthetic joint infections caused by a dental procedure is unknown but is extremely low. Despite the lack of data, most orthopedic surgeons and many general dentists believe antibiotic prophylaxis is needed in patients with prosthetic joint replacements undergoing dental procedures [29]. However, from a risk/benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness perspective, antibiotic prophylaxis does not appear to be warranted [30]. In 1997, the American Dental Association, in conjunction with the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons, published an advisory statement for the use of antibiotic prophylaxis for dental patients with total joint replacements [31]. While recognizing the paucity of data supporting the use of prophylactic antibiotics for dental patients with prosthetic joints, they state that some of these individuals may be at greater risk for infectious complications than others. Those potentially at increased risk for post dental procedure joint infections include patients who have had a joint replacement within the preceding 2 years or patients with total joint replacements who have one of the following conditions: inflammatory arthropathies (rheumatoid arthritis, lupus), immunosuppression, insulin-dependent diabetes, previous prosthetic joint infections, malnourishment, or hemophilia. These at-risk groups can be considered for antibiotic prophylaxis if they undergo a dental or oral procedure likely to cause bacteremia as outlined in the AHA guidelines. The regimens advocated are the same as promulgated by the AHA for dental prophylaxis against endocarditis. Dental patients with orthopedic or do not antibiotic prophylaxis. From the answers to the it should be clear that there is but to to the recommendations of the AHA. It is that with the the American Heart Association will reduce their recommendations to only the very high risk such as previous valvular previous endocarditis, and high risk and change the recommendations for mitral valve prolapse with valvular regurgitation and/or thickened leaflets to be This would recognize the much risk of endocarditis in patients with MVP and account for the potential of prophylaxis to a relatively large group of It would also take into the fact that endocarditis on a mitral valve would be the case with has a much than valve endocarditis on a valve or prosthetic valve endocarditis. there also to be a greater on of oral This should the risk of bacteremias from activities of daily living as as from
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zuckerman et al. (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: