Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The dispute between Iran and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) over the ownership of the islands of Abu Musa, Greater Tunb, and Lesser Tunb is the focus of a broad historical debate, civilizational and ideological confrontation, geopolitical struggle, and economic competition. In addition, it affects some of Russia’s interests. The article reviews the history of the dispute, the positions of the parties, approaches to its qualification and puts forward proposals aimed at its settle-ment. Iran’s position relies on uninterrupted possession of the islands for several millennia, British documents and maps which show tacit acquiescence to its title, and the cession of the islands by Britain in 1971 in accordance with an oral arrangement. It also contests the validity and legitimacy of Arab possession of the islands in the 19th and 20th centuries. The UAE considers Iran’s claims unfounded, citing the peaceful occupation of the islands by the Arab Al Qasimi clan in the 18th and 19th centuries and the concept of consolidation of historical title. The UAE’s claims appear more justified in the light of modern international legal theory and the approaches developed by international tribu-nals. Indeed, territorial titles may be based on effectivités and acts committed during colonial rule; references to facts prior to that rule, by contrast, are irrelevant. Alternative approaches to qualification which ignore the impact of colonial rule and give legal weight to historical arguments and anthropological evidence may lead to different results. Another approach to resolving the dispute is based on the principle of contiguity (proximity), which could provide a basis for compromise and possibly guarantee peace and order in this part of the Persian Gulf. In this case Iran would claim the Tunbs and the UAE would claim Abu Musa. The political landscape in Asia does not always correspond to the political landscape in Europe, which creates a need to develop new legal approaches to resolving territorial disputes. For Russia, this task is not only theoretical but also practical: the potential for conflicts which emerged after the USSR collapsed is far from having been exhausted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vladislav Tolstykh (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: