Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article is a commentary on the article by A.S.Ispolinov “Jurisdictional Reservations (Clauses) in the Practice of the International Court of Justice” published in this issue of International Justice and the article by S.D.Pimenova “The dis-pute between Ukraine and the Russian Federation under the Genocide Convention as the high point of lawfare” pub-lished in the previous issue. The author supports the central thesis of A.S.Ispolinov and S.D.Pimenova, according to which states are now trying to make extensive use of jurisdictional clauses, and develops it by identifying the reasons for this pattern. He also clarifies the concept of lawfare and shows that this phenomenon is linked not only to the in-strumentalisation of justice, but also to the crisis that international law is currently experiencing: this crisis is manifested in the ineffectiveness of its secondary norms, the inability of States to resolve complex political problems and the need to use the idea of a common enemy to legitimise the existing order. The main methodological conclusion is the need to consider the institution of international justice in a broader context, not limited to procedural or substantive issues. International courts are undergoing a profound transformation: not only are they increasingly being used as a regular instrument of international politics, but they are themselves becoming important actors in this politics and, in some cases, dictating their will to states. A state that determines its foreign policy should take courts seriously, i.e. use all the opportunities offered by the international procedural form and make judicial work an obligatory element of the gen-eral strategy for the defence of its interests. The courts established in the post-Soviet space (the CIS Court and the EAEU Court) could be an experimental platform for testing these innovations. The doctrine of international law should also take up this challenge: it is necessary not only to explore existing practice, but also to develop forecasts of the handling of specific cases, judicial rhetoric, political and sociological approaches to international justice, and much more.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vladislav Tolstykh (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: