Why the study?
Does using a Hybrid-OR compared to a mobile x-ray-system improve procedural success or reduce complications in patients undergoing transcatheter aortic valve implantation?
Does using a Hybrid-OR compared to a mobile x-ray-system improve procedural success or reduce complications in patients undergoing transcatheter aortic valve implantation?
Transcatheter aortic valve implantation can be performed with similarly high success rates and safety profiles using either a mobile x-ray system or a dedicated hybrid operating room.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
TAVI achieves high success and safety with either mobile or hybrid imaging; observational data leaves open need for randomized confirmation.
Objective: Only few datas about transcatheter aortic heart valve implantation (THV) are available. We question if there is a difference in using a mobile x-ray-system or a Hybrid-OR. Methods: We refer to 245 patients being treated with Sapien™- THV-implantation during 4/2008–8/2009, focusing implantation parameters and interventional complications. In the first period bioprothesis were implanted at 125 patients (group M) using a mobile x-ray-system (Ziehm-Vision-R), in the second period the implantation proceeded in a Hybrid-OR (Philips-AlluraXper-FD20) at 120 patients (group H). Results: Including-criterias for THV-implantation were a severe aortic stenosis, Euroscore >20% or STS-Score >10% and age >75 years. Transapical method was undertaken in 121 patients (M 58, H 63) whereas 124 patients (M 54, H 70) were treated by transfemoral access. 62.1% of the patients were female, mean age was 81.5 years, mean Euroscore 25.3%. Primary successful results were seen in 97.2% (M 97.6%; H 96.7%), more than 95% without using supporting HLM. A reduction of ΔPmax from 76 to 14mmHg and ΔPmean from 43 to 11mmHg was reached at both groups unaffected by the access. In 92% both groups showed an aortic insufficiency ≤I° after implantation. There were no differences of severe complications (death, conversion, neurological complications) and lower complications (vascular complications, re-thoracotomy, pace-maker-implantation). Conclusion: There is no significant difference between using a mobile x-ray system or a Hybrid-OR for THV-implantation. Working in a Hybrid-OR certainly is more comfortable, especially in cases of vascular complications. Decisive for the successful results of this method is the team-experience.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Schröfel et al. (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: