Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I am proud to be an academic, a value judgement that I hope in some measure to substantiate in this paper, but I have no illusions about the continuing need to re-examine the case for medicine as a university subject.Especially now the credentials for clinical medical education remaining within the university system need to be reaffirmed, so let me briefly mention some views of the purpose of higher education. Purpose of university educationOver a century ago Cardinal Newman argued the case for a non-vocational institution of learning'; he likened the univer- sity to a mental gymnasium, in which, unhampered by practical considerations, the powers of the mind should be generally developed and, thus equipped with principles, be able to tackle problems of the future.Just 20 years ago in a notable essay on the university and medicine Himsworth2 opined that higher education was principally concerned with developing the power to form judgements.He argued that, whereas technological training aims to develop competence in the application of existing specialist knowledge and procedures, university education aims to equip people to deal with problems and situations as yet undefined.He added that, as the unknown cannot be particularised, this higher education must necessarily be broad and representative.A third view is that of Livingstone, the educationist, whose philosophy of the first rate strongly
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Irma Richardson (1975) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: