Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
HE DESIRABLE DEGREE of municipal home rule has been a perennial point of controversy, by no means confined to the United States. As a variety of factors have pushed in the direction of greater centralization, these differences of opinion have understandably sharpened. Experience in the Netherlands, with its well-established democratic tradition, provides an interesting example of an attempt to combine institutions of local self-government with an attitude of strong commitment to nationwide equality of governmental services and of basic national responsibility therefor. The structure and powers of all municipal governments in the Netherlands, from the smallest rural community to the largest city, are identical, with the exception that the size of the council varies with the population. Moreover, the total area of the country is encompassed within these 994 municipalities, most of them thus consisting of both urban and rural territory. Situated between these units and the national government are the eleven provinces, which today perform very few direct services to the public but retain considerable power of supervision over the municipalities. From a legal standpoint the national government is supreme, and no action of a province or municipality may conflict with the constitution or an act of parliament. Likewise, within this limitation a province may preempt all or part of a field. Obviously, therefore, municipalities appear to be left with merely those functions which neither the national government nor the provinces have undertaken, plus a number delegated in whole or in part from the higher levels. In practice, however, there are a number of functions rather traditionally considered municipal responsibilities, even though local officials commonly complain that the scope of these is steadily dwindling. Contrary to United States legal theory, Dutch municipalities are presumed to be able to undertake any function that has not been specifically prohibited to them nor monopolized by the higher levels. It must be remembered that the Netherlands is a small country, its nearly eleven million people crowded into an area approximately equal to that of the state of Maryland. In such circumstances the national government need never seem particularly remote, and all levels and units are rather closely interrelated. Provincial and municipal elections, as well as national, are partisan and the same parties are active at all levels. An additional unifying factor is found in the practice of dual office-holding, it being quite common for an individual to serve simultaneously as a city councilman
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robert L. Morlan (1959) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: