Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Aortic wall thickness has not been demonstrated to be a reliable independent predictor of acute aortic events, and aortic diameter remains a clinically validated risk marker.
Elective ascending aorta replacement is performed with the rationale of preventing catastrophic acute aortic events, namely dissection and more rarely rupture, and is indicated fundamentally on the basis of the diameter. Since the seminal 2007 paper by Pape et al. [1], showing that the diameter is an insufficient parameter to stratify the risk of aortic dissection, this concept has been even excessively stressed out. Indeed, we should not forget that the diameter is a very specific, although poorly sensitive, risk-marker: dissection can occur also at relatively small diameters, yet, frankly dilated aortas are at higher risk for acute events. Therefore, it would be most effective to combine the diameter with another more sensitive risk-marker: to represent a significant addition in risk stratification, this should be loosely correlated with the diameter itself. Can wall thickness be such a risk-marker? The study by Haunshild et al. [2] found no significant correlation of the aortic diameter or other diameter-based indexes, i.e. cross-sectional area to height ratio, aortic size index, aortic height index, to aortic wall thickness. Their take-home message was that aortic diameter is not a good marker for aortic wall weakness and further parameters are needed for better risk stratification: this suggests that in the Authors’ starting assumption wall ‘strength’ or ‘weakness’ should depend on thickness, an approach admittedly centred on the Laplace law. An exemplary practical demonstration of the Laplace law is represented by balloons popping after over-inflation: a similar increase of internal pressure will more easily overcome the strength of a balloon whose diameter is larger or whose membrane thinner [3]. However, no study has found a clear association between aortic wall thinning and acute aortic events, except one small investigation of highly selected connective tissue disorder patients [4]. On the other hand, aortic diameter and derived indexes have all been clinically validated as predictors of acute aortic events (see references 6–8 in Haunshild’s paper [2]). Another investigation [5] found barely significant difference between dissections and aneurysms in terms of wall thickness, only when indexed to the diameter in a subgroup with larger diameter (a mere mathematical trick?). A small radiological study [6] found no difference in terms of aortic wall thickness between pre-dissection computed tomography scans and control aortas, which should suggest no causal role (and no predictive potential) of wall thinning to dissection occurrence. Notably, different criteria (only media, media plus intima, etc.), timing (preoperative, intraoperative, postoperative) and methods (histology, imaging, calliper, etc.) employed to measure wall thickness importantly hinder the comparability of results [2, 4–6], and shed doubt on clinical applicability. Furthermore, the changes in thickness observed in aortopathies, according to the published results, are of a very low order of magnitude (few microns) [2, 4–6]. Therefore, Haunshild and co-workers’ results [2] are interesting but they do not actually add any novel information about appropriateness of diameter as a risk factor: the lack of correlation with wall thickness does not argue against it, because wall thickness is not demonstrated to be proportional to its strength. Nor do those results reveal whether the wall thickness can be a valuable candidate risk-marker: the study included only aneurysms, no controls and no longitudinal observation of events. Unlike in balloons, the factors at play in the aorta are not limited to those of the Laplace law. The aortic wall does not just passively bear intra-luminal pressure, but it also remodels its composition [3], therefore changing its biomechanical properties, including wall strength (failure stress). In this perspective, it is notable that the increase in intimal thickness observed by Haunshild [2] in aneurysms is consistent with our own findings in mild dilatations with aortic valve stenosis [7, 8], a possible hallmark of flow-induced wall tissue remodelling. As Haunshild et al. [2] correctly emphasized, aortic wall biomechanics are fundamental in acute aortic events, therefore we should seek for further stratification criteria indicative of biomechanical properties. Both direct assessment of load-bearing properties by functional imaging methods and indirect test of the tissue remodelling processes by circulating biomarkers [8] assay could help inferring about aortic wall strength.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Corte et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: