Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
COVID-19 has been an unprecedented challenge to many legal systems around the world. In attempting to mitigate the devastating social, economic and political effects of the virus, governments have closed national borders, schools, cinemas and restaurants, ordered lockdowns, strongly recommended that those over 70 years old stay indoors in quarantine-like conditions, banned social gatherings, and encouraged social distancing and the use of face masks. In addition to “normal” legislative measures (or, in some legal systems, administrative rule-making in the form of governmental or ministerial decrees), much of the regulation of COVID-19 has taken place through circulars, instructions, guidance and other soft law norms, the legal status of which is not entirely clear. The articles in this Special Issue focus on the use of such non-binding soft law guidance in dealing with COVID-19 in a comparative perspective. To what extent have national governments and other (central or local) authorities used non-binding soft law guidance – in addition to or instead of binding rules – to stop or to slow down the spread of the virus? To what extent has soft law been used to restrict fundamental and human rights (beyond what was foreseen in binding rules)? If soft law has been used in such a way, have public authorities overstepped constitutional and legal limits? How have courts, lawyers and the public responded to soft law guidance? Reflecting on these questions, the articles contained in this Special Issue compare and critically analyse the uses of soft law in dealing with COVID-19 at EU level, as well as in seven EU Member States (Finland, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Spain, Sweden), China and England. We have chosen to focus on these ten legal systems because of the variousways inwhich the pandemic has impacted them:while Chinawas the first country to be hit, it was soon followed in Europe by Italy and, within only a few weeks, also by other European countries.1 Furthermore, these countries have followed very different approaches to the management of the pandemic, ranging from a full lockdown in China, Italy and Spain to very mild recommendations in Sweden. These differences
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Eliantonio et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: