Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Those of us who champion liberal education have been embattled in recent years, facing a fusillade of criticism.The critiques, which range from the scholarly and philosophical to the polemical and sloganeering, arrive in two varieties: one aimed at practice, the other at theory.Let us call the first sort "narratives of decline." 1 They decry the fallen state of liberal education, identify performance gaps, pinpoint causes, and commend pathways to renewal.Undoubtedly, there are woeful failures, degradations, and perversions of practice in liberal education -although I might say defensively that any complex, institutionalized practice will display regrettable, sometimes even shocking, performance gaps.These critiques, however, are usually jeremiads, bemoaning widespread and systemic degradations.The putative etiology varies, from the abandonment of worthy curricular content to the failure to address the right questions, from the dominance of utilitarian concerns to the triumph of the research ethos, but the pronouncement is the same: the ideal is sound, but everywhere we are failing it, and the practice of liberal education is in decline. 2 Usually, I find it difficult to embrace these worried "friends" of liberal education, because I disagree with their diagnosis of the problem or its supposed scale, because I reject their salvational vision of liberal education, or because their gloom seems willfully to ignore the everyday educational successes that bloom under their noses on their local campuses.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daniel R. DeNicola (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: