Key result
Low-intensity exercise in water increased ventilation output and natriuretic peptides compared to land exercise, while hemodynamic changes were similar.
Why the study?
Does low-intensity exercise performed in water alter cardiorespiratory parameters compared to the same exercise performed on land in healthy subjects?
Does low-intensity exercise performed in water alter cardiorespiratory parameters compared to the same exercise performed on land in healthy subjects?
Low-intensity exercise in water increases ventilatory work and facilitates fluid transfer to the interstitial sector compared to land exercise, without significant hemodynamic differences.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant caution in aquatic prescriptions for cardiorespiratory patients; leaves open clinical relevance pending prospective trials.
The aim of this study was to compare the cardiorespiratory alterations induced by a low-intensity exercise performed on land or in water. Sixteen healthy subjects were investigated. The exercise consisted of a 1-h period of ergocycling at 35%-40% of peak oxygen uptake. Investigations were performed at rest and 45 min after the beginning of the exercises. Hemodynamic changes were studied by Doppler-echocardiography. Gas exchanges were continuously monitored by an oxygen gas analyzer. Blood samples were taken successively at baseline, within the last minutes of the exercise bout, and during recovery to measure total protein concentration and natriuretic peptides. Cardiovascular parameters were not significantly different during exercise performed on land or in water. As a result of an accelerated breathing frequency, ventilation output was significantly greater in water. Biological changes included a decrease in total protein concentration and an increase in natriuretic peptides in water. During low-intensity exercise, ventilatory alterations favoured increasing the work of breathing while in the water when compared with the same exercise performed on land. Hemodynamic changes were similar in the 2 conditions. Furthermore, biological findings suggest that the fluid transfer from intravascular sector toward interstitial sector could be facilitated in water.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ayme et al. (2014) studied Healthy (n=16). Low-intensity exercise in water vs. Low-intensity exercise on land was evaluated on Cardiorespiratory alterations (hemodynamic changes, gas exchanges, and biological changes). Low-intensity exercise in water increased ventilation output and natriuretic peptides compared to land exercise, while hemodynamic changes were similar.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: