Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Globalization andtheSemi-peripheral Condition LEONARDO AVRITZER A SociedadePortuguesa Vetante o Desafioda Globalizaçaoor'Portuguese Society FacingtheChallenge ofGlobalization' isthetitle ofa collection of eight volumes, editedbyBoaventura de Sousa Santos,thatconstitutes the mostup-to-date andsophisticated vision ofPortuguese society produced in a long while.1The eightvolumesare: i. Globalizaçao: Fatalidadeou Utopia?;2. A economiaemcurso:Contextos e mobilidades; 3.Riscosocial e incerteza: Podeo estadosocialrecuar mais?;4.Ateiaglobal:Movimentos sociaise instituiçoes; 5. Enteadosde Galileu:A semi-periferia no sistema mundialda ciencia;6. Transnacionalizacao da educaçao: Da criseda educaçaoà educaçaoda crise; 7.Projecto ecircunstancia: Culturas urbanas em Portugal; and 8. EntreSere Estar:Raizes,percursos e discursos da identidade. The readerwill see in each of thesebooks the sophistication of a collective project, whichis a departure from thecritical perspectives on Portugal, andtherecent processofglobalization. The readerwillalso see thattheaim of theworkis to offer an analysisof Portuguese society unparalleled insophistication inorderto allowitcritically to processits inclusionin a unified Europeand a globalizedworld.The resultis a worthwhile adventure onwhich anyreader interested inPortuguese society shouldembark. Itisnotpossible todojustice toalltheresearch covered inthecollection, becauseofthescope,therichness and thesophistication ofthevarious contributions. I willtherefore focusononlya fewvolumes, beginning with Portuguese identity in Volume8, social movements and the statein Volumes 3and4,andconcluding withglobalization inVolume1. PortugueseIdentityand Globalization: The Semi-Peripheral Condition Northof thesouthand southof thenorth, an empirewitha colonial economy, a country thatwasboththesourceofmigrations andthedestiny ofimmigrations, Portugal and Portuguese identity havealwaysbeenvery difficult to define. Beingtheorigin ofan empire whoseevaluation is still polemic,thePortuguese have beenseenin verydifferent waysbytheir European contemporaries andtheir colonialsubjects. Boaventura deSousa Santospointsto thistensionin his introduction to Volume8, to the contrast between Prosperoand Caliban,thecharacters in Shakespeare's 1 (Porto:EdiçoesAfrontamento, 2001). REVIEW ARTICLE 221 The Tempest.CharlesBoxer,in the role of contemporary European, judgedPortugal inhisPortuguese ColonialEmpireto be an incompetent Prosperobecause of its inability to introducemodernadministrative systems and discipline intoitscolonies.Gilberto Freyre inhisanalysis of theformation ofBrazilshowshowProspero alliedhimself withCalibanin orderto createa newworldinthetropics, thusanticipating manyofthe features ofmulticulturalism and politicaltolerance. To be sure,from an earlytwenty-first-century perspective both Boxer and Freyrecan be criticized fortheirpartialviews:Boxer forjudgingPortugalfroman excessively instrumental perspective; Freyre, foridealizing thecolonizer. Thistension hasitsbackground Os Portugueses nuncapuderaminstalar-se comodamenteno espaco-tempooriginàrio do Prosperoeuropeu.Viveramnesseespaço-tempocomo que internamente deslocados emregiöessimbólicasque lhesnao pertenciam e ondenao se sentiamà vontade.Foram objecto de humilhaçaoe de celebraçao, de estigmatizaçaoe de complacencia,mas semprecom a distanciade quem nao é plenamente comtemporâneo do espaço-tempo que ocupa. Forçadosa jogaro jogo dos binarismos modernos, tiveram dificuldades em saberde que lado estavam.Nem ProsperonemCaliban, restou-lhes a liminaridade e a fronteira, a inter-identidade cornoidentidade originària, (vili,53-54) Volume8 illustrates severalfeatures ofthehybrid identity constituted by thePortuguese in theircoloniesor byPortuguese migrants in theirnew countries. BelaFeldman Bianco,ina fine article onthePortuguese inBrazil andBrazilians inPortugal, initiates this construction. SheshowshowBrazil was fora longwhilethemainreceptor ofPortuguese migrants and how Portugal's entry intotheEuropeanCommunity redefined thisconnection. Here we see the development of a specificPortuguese identity. This relationship with former coloniestookplaceatthesametime thatEngland was a sourceofmigration forunskilled workers (Clara Keating'sessay, 'RelocatedLanguages:Discursive itineraries oftwoPortuguese womenin London',showsthisfaceofPortuguese migration). Thisfeature showsa very singular colonizer, a colonizer whocouldneverbecomea European Prosperobut was able to establisha verydifferent heritage. In Nuno Porto'sessayon thePortuguese inAngolathesetwodimensions become clear.NunoPortoaskswhata EuropeanProspero shoulddo inAfrica. He correctly pointsout the answer:introduceknowledge,practicesand disciplinary institutions characteristic ofthemodern state(p. 218). However , Portoalso indicates thatthemainelements ofthisproject havefailed to be implemented in Angola,or onlypartially implemented, due to the weakness ofstate administrative structures. Asa result there arecompromises .Aplanned anthropological museum tobeconstructed intheEuropean style isreplaced bya roomforfolkmusic, for which resources areavailable and whichseemsto fitmoreto thelocal reality. Thesearethedilemmas analysed in'Entre Sere Estar',dilemmas created bya colonialprocess that 222 LEONARDO AVRITZER hasgenerated a hybrid, something between colonizer andcolonized.This hybrid has a sociologicalconsequence thatSousa Santoscalls thesemiperipheral condition, thatistosaythecondition ofcountries thatconnect thecentre andtheperiphery, as Portugal hasdoneforsolongbyconnecting BrazilandEngland. Asa result, bothcountries andcultures endupsharing characteristics ofboth(p.287). The case ofglobalization inPortugal involves precisely thisdimension: beinganemigrant country itself, andbeing bothpartofthecentre andpart of theperiphery, Portugal changedconsiderably withglobalization precisely becauseitglobalized itself byjoining theEuropeancommunity, that is to say by joiningthecentre.Yet,in thisprocessit brought withit Brazilian andAfrican immigrants, a semi-peripheral economy, theleftovers ofa corporatist authoritarian regime andmanyotherfeatures thatforso longhavebeenrecognized as beingpartofthesemi-periphery. Whathas changed inglobalizedPortugal andhowhavethesehybrid characteristics adaptedthemselves toglobalization? Social Movementsand the State ina Globalized Portugal Volume3, 'Risco sociale incerteza: Podeo estadosocialrecuarmais?'is editedbyPedroHespanhaand Graça Carapinheiro...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Leonardo Avritzer (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: