Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
226 Reviews Kokoschka and Gerstl. A final chapter on Wittgenstein ismore expansive, and tellingly explores the relation of the public, the private and the downright secret. Drawing onWittgenstein's use of a coded language in some notebooks, themixing of personal and philosophical jottings, and the suppression ofmaterial linked to his repressed homosexuality in thepublication of the early diaries (1914-16), Le Rider argues for a greater degree of continuity between this early phase and the later phase documented innotebooks from the 1930s. The mingling ofprivate notes with spiritual and philosophical thinking, and themaking public of these in the form of scholarly or critical editions prompts a fascinating parallel with Pascal (pp. 385-87). Le Rider undoubtedly stretches the definition of journaux intimes' tomake it serve as a refreshing perspective on a familiar period, and the degree towhich his subjects qualify for inclusion even under the generously interpreted heading is sometimes slightly tenuous. Quibbles apart, however, what emerges from this readable and stimulating study is a clear sense that themost personal and intimate of forms is paradoxically amongst themost revelatory of the true impact of the broader crises in culture, society and politics that characterized the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries inVienna. Royal Holloway University of London Robert Vilain Rethinking Vienna igoo. Ed. by Steven Beller. (Austrian History, Culture and Society 3). New York and Oxford: Berghahn. 2001. 292 pp. $69.95; ?47??? (hardback), isbn 1?57181 ?139?7. $25.00; ?17.00 (paperback), isbn 1-57181-140-0. Wittgenstein'sViennaRevisited.By Allan S. Janik. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers. 2001. 287 pp. $49.95. isbn 0-7658-0050-0. Few would dispute that the burgeoning state ofAustrian Studies as an anglophone subset ofAuslandsgermanistikisenormously indebted to two seminal American works of the 1970s: Allan Janik's and Stephen Toulmin's Wittgenstein'sVienna (1973) and Carl E. Schorske's Fin-de-Siecle Vienna.Politics and Culture (1980). In thismagisterial work, in fact a collection of essays firstpublished between 1961 and 1979, Schorske advances the thesis that the cauldron of creativity which was 'Vienna 1900' can largely be ascribed to the collapse of political liberalism and the attendant retreat into the 'cultural temple of the aesthetic and psychological, where the external, historical world held no sway' (Beller, p. 3). Elegantly written and beautifully produced, Schorske's book remains a classic, not least in theway it shows how fruitfultruly interdisciplinary thinking can be. It isa tribute to Schorske's lasting impact thatRethinkingVienna igoo isessentially an extended exercise ingrappling with his legacy, and inparticular his now much challenged central paradigm, the 'failure of liberalism'. With contributions from predominantly American scholars on subjects ranging fromHerzl and Schaukal to Freud and Popper, the work is clearly wide-ranging, and the overall quality of individual contributions ishigh. Of particular value isSteven Beller's introduction, which acts as a short history ofAustrian Studies from the 1970s onwards. Allan Janik outlines his ideas on 'criticalmodernism', which he will develop at length in his own book, while James Schedel also discusses at length the implications of nomenclature for our understanding of thisperiod. Is ita caesura that underlines AUSTRIAN STUDIES, II, 2OO3 227 the historical abnormality of an Austrian Sonderweg (?Fin de Si?cle'), or is it 'a transitional moment that points to a unique but hardly deviant continuity of historical development' ('Jahrhundertwende') (p. 81)? Although there is ample reference to thevisual arts, including Ilona S?rm?ny-Parsons's fascinating review of 'The Image ofWomen in Painting', which, however, is only marginally about Vienna, there is not a single contribution on a musical topic. And this in a book entitledRethinkingVienna igoo. Throughout thisvolume, which is theoutcome of a conference held at theCenter forAustrian Studies at theUniversity of Minnesota, Schorske's work is subjected to sustained, and not always friendly, critique. The result of this is tomake the reader more aware than ever of Schorske's own, uniquely broad achievement inFin-de Si?cle Vienna.As Steven Beller properly notes inhis preface, we do well to remember that without Schorske's 'pioneering work in exploring ? in some ways even creating ? the field, this volume would not have been possible' (p. ix). Not unusually, great claims are made by the publisher on...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Andrew Barker (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: