Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The efficient and cost-effective realization and implementation of hydrogen and fuel cell technologies in the existing energy and transport systems require appropriate laws (regulations), standards and processes (“Regulations, Codes and Standards”—RCS). Almost all relevant regulations that are applicable to hydrogen and fuel cells in Germany today are based on, or must be adapted in, European legislation (directives or regulations). Likewise, the essential part of the standards used today is, or will be, harmonized with international (ISO, IEC) or European (EN) standards. New standards are essentially developed only within the framework of ISO, IEC or CEN, CENELEC. For example, in 2017, approximately 75% of the new standards relevant for Europe were international and only 20% European standards. Hydrogen (H₂) and Fuel Cell (FC) technologies are developed worldwide, especially in Asia, Europe and North America. This influence is also reflected in important regulations and standards for hydrogen (H₂ RCS). Due to the path of regulatory development via the New Legislative Framework adopted by the European Commission, the relevant actors have to anticipate, synchronize and harmonize the development of standards and regulations. Hence, an increased representation of German experts is required in all relevant international standardization committees. Consequently—in order to ensure the representation of Germany's interests in the future—a more active participation in committee work is required, particularly within the EU, UNECE, ISO, IEC, CEN and CENELEC. The development of standards and regulations and, in particular, the coordination between the two is complex and requires a concerted approach and substantial efforts. For this reason, the development of a roadmap strategy paper [1] was commissioned by NOW GmbH and hence prepared by LBST GmbH, in order to identify potentials and obstacles in a hydrogen RCS context. Furthermore, expedient measures and instruments have been identified, which could be implemented within a certain timeline to foster the involvement of German players in the establishment of a beneficial regulatory framework for hydrogen and FC technologies. The progress of this implementation must be regularly reviewed and, where appropriate, be adapted to changing requirements. As the topics with the biggest needs for action have been identified in the following ones: In order to understand the complexity of RCS and the variety and multitude of aspects to be considered, some observations and clarifications have to be given at first hand. In almost all countries, standards are voluntary definitions of minimum requirements (see Figure 1) for interfaces between technological components or of such components with other systems or of technologies that use common elements shared by different platforms, sub-systems or systems. Standards intend to provide precise descriptions guaranteeing the compatibility of the related items through a written text agreed in scope and content among those developing such standards documents, typically standard developing organizations (SDOs). Standards can constitute barriers and protect commercial interests and at worst even impair innovations. On the other hand, standards can facilitate a harmonized market access, manufacturing and wide-spread use. In general, standards shall not be design but performance-oriented [3]. The only country where standards exist, which immediately have legal relevance and are mandatory to be applied, is China with its GB standards [4]. In most other countries or regions, standard may acquire legal relevance when referenced from legislation, like in the EU when referenced from a regulation or a directive. In order to simplify and harmonize the regulatory process, some governments have adopted the practice to write legal documents based on existing widely harmonized standards, see Figure 2. The European Union uses this approach in its so-called New Legislative Framework (NLF) [5] in order to harmonize legal requirements EU-wide with as limited efforts as possible by referring to existing international standards (ISO, IEC, EN). Which standards may be referenced is regulated in the EU Regulation on Standardization EU/1025/2012. One of the most prominent results of this legislative process in the hydrogen sector in Europe is the Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Directive (AFID) 2014/94/EU. When referencing three existing standards for hydrogen in ANNEX II of this Directive in 2014, rapidly it turned out that these standards still needed improvement, were premature or did not sufficiently ensure EU-wide interoperability of the addressed hydrogen infrastructure. Consequently, in March 2015, the EC had to issue mandate M 533 and to order CEN to revise these standards (ISO/TS 20100, ISO 14687-2, ISO 17268). In German approval processes, using standards for specific technologies and applying these analogically to other comparable technologies, which are lacking availability of explicit rules, is accepted practice. In other countries this is not the case. This pragmatic and well-structured German approval process has so far allowed Germany to act with relatively low international reconcilement efforts. Nowadays, however, the NLF approach requires a significantly increased commitment in standardization as well as regulatory bodies, especially with regard to the national implementation of applicable/mandatory rules. Generally speaking, players need simple regulations and standards that are practical and easy to implement. In order to achieve this in a staged approach, the following implications have to be observed and addressed: Prerequisite to develop an understanding of how best to deal with the different aspects of RCS: The benefit of harmonized RCS for stakeholders from the hydrogen and fuel cell industry consists of: As the relevant international RCS bodies for participation and coordination, the following are suggested: with respect to regulations: Within the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UN ECE) Global technical regulations on hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEV) with respect to standards: Figure 3 visualizes the hierarchy and legal function of German national as well as international RCS, structured according to their level of detail. In the following Figure 4, the most important needs for action as displayed in the German H2-Roadmap 2025 and their anticipated timelines are illustrated: The topological integration of the German legislation into the European and international regulatory framework is shown in Figure 5: The latter indicates that—according to German legislation—technical rules for operational safety (TRBS), which reflect the state of the art and ensure the implementation of the Ordinance on Industrial Safety (BetrSichV) as issued by the German Federal Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs, have to be complied with in addition to the international and European framework legislation. It has become clear in these RCS activities over the last years that sometimes not all international standards and regulations can be implemented nationally or regionally without certain adaptations required by national legislation. Simultaneously, not all specific national legislative requirements can be agreed upon in the international committees at UN or ISO. Furthermore, many national laws cannot be adapted to such a degree that international standards or regulations could be transplanted 1:1. As two prominent examples may serve the following: the UN GTR13 on type approval of FCEVs and ISO 19880-1 on layout, operation and maintenance of HRSs. Certain Chinese requirements might not be accepted in the present modification process of GTR 13 and thus—even if China adopts the final GTR 13-II in its GB—some additional requirements may have to be included. Regarding ISO 19880-1, an international standard cannot include all local specificities as standards try to cover minimum requirements only. Consequently, the European AFID required certain interoperability needs that were not covered by this ISO standard. Hence, the development of a European standard—EN 17127—was initiated to address these while still being harmonized with the respective ISO document as much as possible. Analogous to the standards EN 17124 on hydrogen quality and quality control (harmonized with ISO 14687 and ISO 19880-8) and EN ISO 17268 on refuelling connection devices, EN 17127 is now referenced from the AFID and legally binding. The development of a harmonized position on hydrogen and fuel cell relevant RCS, per country, per region and globally has been identified as very desirable, efficient and effective. Harmonization efforts at all levels of legislation and standards development—including the alignment between both—where required, necessary or advisable have started, are on-going or still have to be initiated in some cases. These international efforts typically occur on the level of UN, EU, ISO and IEC bodies. Although the three large economic areas of China, the EU and North America could agree on regulations and standards for their regions separately, harmonizing specifications and interfaces of components and sub-systems on a global level makes a lot of sense due to the international exchange between these regions—especially with regard to the fast economic growth of both Asian and African countries. In this context, harmonization could contribute significantly to economic efficiency by limiting the number of solutions required (eg, with respect to materials and quality control), hence fostering the implementation of hydrogen and fuel cell applications in national, regional and global markets. The establishment of a national H2 RCS coordination platform has been identified as a useful instrument to achieve a successful implementation of regulatory and normative requirements while involving all relevant actors and stakeholders. Major tasks of this platform could include, but are not limited to: The research was funded by the German BMVI (Federal Ministry of Transport and Digital Infrastructure).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wurster et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: