Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Three-part study repairs and clarifies the classification of rational-derived quartics, suggesting implications for Conjecture 1.
A polynomial over Q is rational-derived if it and all of its derivatives split completely over Q. Buchholz and MacDougall (J. Number Theory 81 (2000)) presented a classification of rational-derived quartics, their Theorem 7, whose four-distinct-root clause is entangled with their Conjecture 1. We report a three-part study of this classification, conducted through a Lean 4 formalization. First, an audit: the published proof of Theorem 7 contains a circularity and a quantifier gap — the argument assumes that the critical vertical translate is rational-derived, an assumption equivalent to the splitting it is required to prove (the equivalence is kernel-certified), and then concludes universally without discharging it; a single quartic, read over two base fields, refutes over Q the implication left once the circular assumption is removed, and over Q(sqrt(3441)) the statement's natural analogue under the full K-derived hypothesis. Second, a repair: Theorem 7′, a rank-free image theorem identifying the normalised p(2,1,1) sector exactly with the image of the rational points of the elliptic curve E: z² = w(w−6)(w+18) (Cremona 576i2) under an explicit rational map — which, together with a kernel-verified affine normalisation and the elementary multiplicity cases, yields an unconditional classification of all repeated-root quartics; both directions reduce to explicit polynomial certificates together with elementary field and order arguments, and no rank computation enters — a proof found because the library lacked Mordell–Weil rank. The main statement compiles with axiom footprint exactly [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]. Third, a boundary: a kernel-verified bridge identifies the normalised form of Conjecture 1 with the nonexistence of nondegenerate rational points on an explicit splitting surface; the three double covers governing the vertical-translate route are proved nontrivial over the splitting extension, with the kernel boundary of each claim marked in the text, and the fibre correspondence between the disjuncts of Theorem 7 and those covers is closed in the kernel. Conjecture 1 itself remains open: this development maps its boundary, it does not resolve it. The formalization detected the gap, sharpened the statements, and certified the repair; we record the mathematics together with the lessons of the formalization.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hiroki Fukui (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: