Why the study?
Does bicarbonate hemodialysis affect oxygenation compared to acetate hemodialysis in male chronic dialysis patients?
Does bicarbonate hemodialysis affect oxygenation compared to acetate hemodialysis in male chronic dialysis patients?
Bicarbonate hemodialysis significantly increases P50 compared to acetate hemodialysis, though the mechanism is independent of 2.3 DPG concentration and red cell volume.
No change in dialysis buffer selection; leaves open clinical relevance of oxygenation shifts in chronic hemodialysis.
We studied the effect of bicarbonate and acetate on oxygenation during dialysis in ten male chronic dialysis patients. The dialysis delivery system and dialysate constituents were identical except for the use of either bicarbonate or acetate. We found no hemodynamic differences between the two kinds of dialysis. Blood PO2 fell by a similar amount, but blood PCO2 was higher during bicarbonate dialysis. The blood pH became alkalotic by the second hour of bicarbonate dialysis and remained so throughout the dialysis, whereas blood pH became alkalotic only at the end of acetate dialysis. The P50 increased significantly only during bicarbonate dialysis, but 2.3 DPG concentration did not change. Red cell volume, assessed by the mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration, was unchanged. Without changes in the red cell volume we cannot explain the observed changes in P50 in the absence of concomitant changes in 2.3 DPG concentration.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ramírez et al. (1987) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 4 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: