Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We read with interest the work of Pérez-Bracchiglione et al. Managing overlap of primary studies in overviews of reviews has repeatedly been identified as one of the main methodological challenges encountered when conducting overviews.1–3 Pérez-Bracchiglione et al.’s newly developed tool, ‘Graphical Representation of Overlap for OVErviews: GROOVE tool’, is a valuable and timely addition to the growing body of literature guiding the optimal conduct of overviews of systematic reviews and the challenges of overlap management. The GROOVE tool provides visualization methods of overlap and provides guidance for managing temporally impossible overlap – referred to as chronologic structural ‘missingness’. In this response to Pérez-Bracchiglione et al., we would like to highlight the importance of these novel overlap management strategies, describe our experience with the GROOVE overlap methods, and propose three additional considerations for overlap management – 1. Describing chronologic structural missingness, 2. Addressing overlap at the outcome level and 3. Identifying unique trials. Whilst conducting an overview of systematic reviews on the clinical and pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamics outcomes of prolonged infusions of beta-lactam antimicrobials, our research team used the corrected-covered area (CCAs) to describe overlap between included systematic reviews. In our opinion, this single summary statistic was easy to calculate but difficult to interpret by itself. To complement our CCA calculations the visualization methods presented by Pérez-Bracchiglione at the Cochrane Colloquium 2019, now published in Research Synthesis Methods, were used to guide a more granular and focused evaluation of overlap between each possible pair of systematic reviews. Given the broad scope and heterogeneous nature of interventions and outcomes included in our overview, understanding the implications of overlap at the individual systematic review level further enabled our assessment of overlap as it related to our research question. This granular visual representation of overlap of each pair of systematic reviews, juxtaposed with information about the study population, intervention and outcomes, allows understanding of where and why there is overlap. We have found this critical to interpreting the relevance of overlap when interpreting overview findings, particularly when
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thabet et al. (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: