Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
INTRODUCTION The categorical model of personality disorders that had been adopted in previous revisions of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) as well as in previous editions of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) is generally regarded as obsolete. The model has poor inter-rater reliability, poor stability over time, poor discriminate validity and poor general coverage of personality disorder [1,2]. In addition, and notwithstanding an impressive body of research on borderline personality disorder, very little to no research studies has been done on most of the other personality disorders [3]. In the meantime, attention has shifted to dimensional models [4] and the Personality and Personality Disorders Work Groups for both ICD-11 and DSM-5 have developed new models for classifying these disorders. A new, hybrid, categorical–dimensional model that had been developed for DSM-5 was not, however, retained by the Board of Trustees of the American Psychiatric Association, who decided to ‘to preserve continuity with current clinical practice’ and ‘to maintain the current approach to personality disorders’, that is to keep the model that had been introduced in previous editions and maintained with only minor changes up to DSM-IV-TR. The new model was relegated to Section III, labeled ‘Emerging Measures and Models’ containing ‘tools and techniques to enhance the clinical decision-making process, understand the cultural context of mental disorders, and recognize emerging diagnoses for further study’. In the meantime, the personality disorders workgroup for ICD-11 has developed a dimensional model, which is slated to replace the categorical model that had been included in the ICD up to ICD-10. As such, clinicians, researchers and other stakeholders, most notably patients, may choose, in the years to come and for an as yet unknown duration, between three widely different models for classifying personality disorders: a categorical model, a hybrid model and a dimensional model. Each of the three models has its advantages, but each also has its drawbacks or at the very least a ‘fly in the ointment’. THE ‘OFFICIAL’ PART OF DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDERS – FIFTH EDITION AND THE CATEGORICAL MODEL In the official part of DSM-5, the general diagnostic criteria and algorithm defining personality disorder as well as the individual diagnostic criteria and algorithms defining each specific personality disorder are identical with those in DSM-IV-TR. In addition, all of the 10 specific personality disorders identified in DSM-IV-TR are retained in DSM-5, that is paranoid personality disorder, schizoid personality disorder, schizotypal personality disorder, antisocial personality disorder, borderline personality disorder, histrionic personality disorder, narcissistic personality disorder, avoidant personality disorder, dependent personality disorder and obsessive–compulsive personality disorder, as well as a category of ‘other specified and unspecified personality disorder’. PART III OF DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDERS – FIFTH EDITION AND THE ALTERNATIVE, HYBRID MODEL The new model that had been developed for DSM-5 but that had not been retained, is a hybrid, dimensional–categorical model. The diagnosis of a personality disorder is based on the presence of significant impairment in personality functioning, and the presence of one or more pathological personality traits. Impairment in personality functioning implies impairment in self-functioning characterized by disturbances concerning a person's sense of identity and self-direction and impairment in self-functioning characterized by disturbances with regard to a person's capacity for empathy and intimacy. Impairment in these elements is assessed using a Level of Personality Functioning Scale (LPFS) which differentiates five levels, ranging from 0 (no impairment) to some (1), moderate (2), severe (3) and 4 (extreme). For a diagnosis of personality disorder, the presence of at least a moderate level of impairment is required. The model includes 25 pathological personality traits organized into five domains: negative affectivity, detachment, antagonism, disinhibition and psychoticism. The five domains and 25 traits are considered maladaptive variants of the five domains and facets of the ‘Big Five’ or ‘Five Factor Model’ of personality. The maladaptive domains and traits can be assessed using a formal psychometric instrument such as the Personality Inventory for DSM-5 (PID-5). The clinician will have to decide whether a specific trait is sufficiently elevated to be relevant for a diagnosis of personality disorder. On the basis of the particularities of the impairment in functioning and the characteristics of the pathological traits, the alternative model identifies six specific types of personality disorder, that is, antisocial, avoidant, borderline, narcissistic, obsessive–compulsive and schizotypal. Patients presenting with personality disease but not meeting criteria for any of the six specific personality disorders may be given an unspecific diagnosis called ‘Personality disorder-trait specified’. Four personality disorders included in DSM-IV-TR, that is, paranoid, schizoid, histrionic and dependent personality disorders are not part of the alternative DSM-5 model [3]. The hybrid model has met with significant criticism, including from members of the Personality and Personality Disorders Work Group itself. According to Livesley [5], ‘the basic structure of the model is seriously flawed, in particular because it is too complex for routine clinical work. It incorporates two separate classifications, one typal the other dimensional, replacing the disorders of DSM-IV by two distinct sets of higher-order constructs, i.e. six types and five domains, and it is not clear how clinicians are supposed to use such a system’. According to Verheul [6], the new model is ‘a heroic and innovative but nevertheless fundamentally flawed attempt to improve DSM-IV’. In particular, ‘it fails to retain user acceptability, accuracy and reliability, it lacks empirical support and is far too complex for the average clinician and does not provide a coherent framework for reliable diagnosis’. THE INTERNATIONAL CLASSIFICATION OF DISEASE, ELEVENTH REVISION AND THE DIMENSIONAL MODEL Led by Peter Tyrer, The International Classification of Disease, Eleventh Revision (ICD-11) Personality and Personality Disorder Work Group has developed a model that abolishes all type specific categories of personality disorder apart from the general one of personality itself. As specified in the beta draft of ICD-11, ‘Personality disorder is characterized by a relatively enduring and pervasive disturbance in how individuals experience and interpret themselves, others and the world in maladaptive patterns of cognition, emotional experience, emotional expression, and behavior. These maladaptive patterns are relatively inflexible and are associated with significant problems in psychosocial functioning that are particularly evident in interpersonal relationships’. The ICD-11 beta draft proposes five severity levels of personality disturbance: ‘no personality disorder’ (no personality disturbance), ‘personality difficulty’ (some personality problems in certain situations but not universally), and ‘mild’, ‘moderate’ and ‘severe’ personality disorder. Mild personality disorder is defined by ‘definite well demarcated personality problems across a range of situations’, moderate personality disorder by ‘definite personality problems usually covering several personality domains and across all situations’, and severe personality disorder as ‘a complex disorder with personality problems leading to significant risk to self or others’. This dimensional approach to assessing severity of personality disorders appears to have more clinical utility, which has been an overarching objective of ICD-11. The personality features of individuals diagnosed with a personality disorder or personality difficulty may be characterized using prominent trait domain descriptors or ‘qualifiers’. The draft of the ICD-11 model proposes five qualifiers, namely ‘prominent anankastic features’, ‘prominent features of detachment’, ‘prominent features of disinhibition’, ‘prominent dissocial features’ and ‘prominent features of negative affectivity’. Trait domains are characterized by prominent features and specific traits. As an example, prominent anankastic features are characterized by ‘a narrow focus on the control and regulation of one's own and others’ behavior in order to ensure that things conform to the individual's particularistic ideal. Specific traits include perfectionism, perseveration, emotional and behavioural constraint, stubbornness, deliberativeness, orderliness, and concern with following rules and meeting obligations’. The limitations of a purely dimensional approach as described in the beta draft of the ICD-11 have been discussed extensively in a recent article by Herpertz et al.[7]. The authors outline nine major limitations of the current proposal and conclude that the ICD-11 model is ‘based on broad, potentially stigmatizing descriptions of impaired functioning and ignores much of the impressive body of research and treatment guidelines that have advanced the care of adults and adolescents with borderline and other PDs’. The authors argue that ‘before radically changing classification, which highly impacts the provision of healthcare, head-to head field trials coupled with the views of patients as well as thorough debate among scientists are urgently needed’. Indeed, as we know from the past experience, radical changes of our diagnostic classification systems create a number of problems and represent barriers for longitudinal and comparative monitoring of mental disorders across time and settings. The status of borderline personality disorder is of particular importance in this context. At the recent World Congress of Psychiatry in Berlin, Peter Tyrer presented a slide arguing that ‘patients currently labelled borderline personality disorder are a heterogeneous group with the majority having Axis I and Axis II comorbidity’ and proposing a borderline personality disorder specifier for patients who fulfil the criteria. Clinicians could then choose to use domains to further specify diagnosis, for example, borderline personality disorder: predominantly negative affective, borderline personality disorder: predominantly disinhibited, borderline personality disorder predominantly dissocial and borderline personality disorder (with) some combination of this. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION Whatever the shortcomings or ‘flies in the ointment’ of the alternative model in DSM-5 or the actual model in ICD-11, there is little doubt that the days of any type of categorical model for classifying personality disorders are over. In particular, recent findings suggest that ‘little information is lost in a transition to trait domain models’. The same authors argue that the ICD-11 and the alternative DSM-5 model for classifying personality disorder’ may be used to delineate one another as well as features of familiar categorical personality disorder types’ [8]. Acknowledgements None. Financial support and sponsorship None. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pull et al. (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: