Key result
Inadequate mitral valvotomy yields good long-term outcomes in ~57% of patients without calcification.
Why the study?
Many early mitral valvotomy cases had unexpectedly good results despite operations considered inadequate by contemporary standards, prompting an investigation of cases with a final valve size of 2.5 cm. or less.
Observational (n=68)
No
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Investigates the unexpected clinical improvement in mitral stenosis patients who underwent inadequate valvotomy (final valve size ≤2.5 cm).
In a review of the results of mitral valvotomy (Fraser and Kerr, 1961) we were surprised to find that many of the early cases in the series had a good result in spite of what would be considered, by present standards, to be an inadequate operation.This group of cases seemed to merit further study; thus the fate of all cases with a final valve size of 2.5 cm. or less was investigated. Material and MethodOut of 150 consecutive valvotomies performed by one of us (K.F.) during 1951-7, 68 had a final valve size of 2.5 cm. or less.All operations were performed by the transatrial route, using the finger or a Brock's knife to achieve the "split."Eleven (16 %) patients have died since operation: the cause of death was congestive cardiac failure in nine and cerebral embolus in two.Twenty-one cases have had re-operation, the details of which have already been published (Fraser and Kerr, 1962).Of the remaining 36, 35 have been traced and reviewed.When the patients were seen at the follow-up, account was taken of their exercise tolerance, liability to bronchitis, haemoptysis, and chest pain, and their digitalis requirements.Clinical, electrocardiographic, and chest x-ray examination of each patient was carried out.The results of the operation were graded as poor, good, or very good, depending upon our assess- ment of exercise tolerance.Fifteen cases were graded as poor and 20 as good or very good.In an attempt to explain the variation in results these two groups were compared under the following headings: (1) duration of symptoms before operation; (2) age at operation; (3) findings at operation; (4) time interval between operation and assessment; (5) clinical findings at assessment; (6) chest x-ray findings; (7) E.C.G. records; (8) histology of pulmonary lingula biopsies. ResultsDuration of Symptoms Before Operation (Table I).-Of the 20 patients with good results 10 had had symptoms for less TABLE I.-Duration of Symptoms Before Operation Years: 2-4-6-8-10+ Total Good result ..
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fraser et al. (1964) conducted an observational in Mitral stenosis (n=68). Technically inadequate transatrial mitral valvotomy (final valve size ≤2.5 cm) vs. Good/very good clinical result (n=20) vs poor clinical result (n=15) at follow-up was evaluated on Good or very good clinical result based on exercise tolerance at 5-10 years among traced un-reoperated survivors.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: