This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Medicine is of course a stressful career. Long hours of caring for sick people, some of whom will never get better or might inevitably die, takes strength of character as well as physical stamina. The picture is the same worldwide. In developed countries, where resources are relatively plentiful, health care costs are spiralling, and governments see a need to limit services or make extensive cuts. In developing countries, the dilemmas of providing health care, especially in rural communities, seem overwhelming, with the added catastrophes of drought, war and AIDS. Health care workers there have to set priorities for which a university education must seem remote. The education which prepares doctors for a medical career should respond to these challenges. However, medical education itself is a contributor to stress. During the undergraduate phase medical students are damagingly overloaded with content, and the relevance of much of what they are taught often eludes them. Vast amounts of information are committed to memory for dubious reasons and doubtful benefit. In the clinical years students find themselves unable to apply in a professional setting what they knew well enough for the examinations. Postgraduate medical training is hardly better. Newly qualified doctors find themselves ill prepared for what they are expected to do, and many say they are insufficiently supported by their seniors. The protracted scramble for promotion is exacerbated by the burden of preparation for postgraduate examinations in the limited time left after a busy day. Having made it to the top, consultants discover they must function as managers for which most have never been trained, and doctors in post face a further 30 years without adequate provision for continuing medical education. In this issue of Medical Education, six specially commissioned articles give differing perspectives on stress management in medical education. Wolf presents an in-depth literature review, and discusses the sources of stress and the consequences on the physical and psychological well-being of students. Hall & Miller describe the circumstances in North America, and review the health policy of medical schools there. Coles describes the situation in the United Kingdom, and discusses how the undergraduate and postgraduate medical education systems are responding to change. Pasnau & Stoessel describe mental health services for doctors in training, and Ackerman & Wall outline a programme for treating chemically dependent medical students. Finally, Coombs & Virshup describe the establishment of a ‘well-being’ committee at a North American medical school. Taken together, these articles present a case which those responsible for medical education at both undergraduate and postgraduate levels need urgently to address. Four elements of the task to be tackled can be singled out. First, the curriculum itself is a major source of stress. Overload of information, much of it of dubious relevance, is presented to students in a context which is far removed from its eventual use. Even when students have contact with patients, the links between their theoretical courses and clinical experiences is often tenuous. Examinations are sometimes not defensible educationally and to students appear as hurdles to be surmounted rather than opportunities for assessing progress. Second, many medical teachers have never been taught to teach. A predominantly lecture system requires them to present information impersonally to large groups of students. Even small-group teaching can become monologues by teachers who may never have learnt the necessary skills. Bedside teaching too often has its own defects, which some clinical teachers recognize but lack the resources to ameliorate. Faced with the frustration of students not knowing what they are supposed to have learnt, some clinicians even today deploy a style of teaching by humiliation. Third, the climate of much medical education is often unsupportive and threatening where it should be collaborative. Vacuous high achievement is sometimes rewarded, and an unhealthy competitiveness often fostered. Medical education may succeed tolerably well in teaching technical knowledge and skills and in carrying out health-related research, but it often fails to produce well-adjusted students, accomplished in communication skills, who are properly self-caring and compassionate. Fourth, a number of medical schools still do not provide adequate support services for students and trainees, either to prevent the harmful effects of stress, or to deal satisfactorily with them once they have developed. Fostering the personal welfare of students requires vision as well as effort. Curricula need to be reformed so that students are treated as the adults they are. Teachers must be enabled to become facilitators of learning, and teaching excellence should be rewarded in the same way clinical excellence and research scholarship now are. Unless students and trainees learn how to study effectively they cannot readily become lifelong learners. They should acquire too the skills of time management and the ability to cope with the stresses of medical life. The need for more research is glaringly obvious to identify more precisely the nature of stress in medical education and its consequences for the physical and psychological well-being of medical students and postgraduate trainees. International collaboration is required as well to develop policies to cover a lifetime of stress in a medical career.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
C. R. COLES (1994) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: