Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This manuscript reports on invariant projections of cycle spaces in polyhedral graphs, implying unique characterizations for regular solids.
Version 2. Manuscript updated to v1.10 (8 August 2026), which closes the residual case of the main theorem via Proposition 9.6d. Adds the verification scripts, their recorded output, and the census data, which were not included in version 1. Abstract Let Γ be the skeleton of a convex polyhedron, with cycle space H₁(Γ) and cut space K(Γ), and set c(Γ) = dim HomAut(Γ)(H₁(Γ), K(Γ)). By a theorem of Dilworth, Kutzarova and Ostrovskii, c(Γ) = 0 is equivalent to uniqueness of the invariant projection of the signed edge space onto H₁(Γ). We determine c for every convex polyhedron. First, we prove the orbit formula c(Γ) = N(F × V) − N(F) − N(V) + δ, where N counts automorphism-group orbits whose stabiliser contains no orientation-reversing element and δ is the chirality correction. We then prove duality invariance and show that c(Γ) = 0 if and only if Γ is the graph of a Platonic solid. The converse reduces vanishing to a covering condition by mirror planes, forcing vertex directions and face axes onto finitely many rotation axes; a finite forced-ratio enumeration closes the polyhedral reflection groups and uniform arguments settle the axial families. We also give closed formulas for chiral toroidal maps and counterexamples showing that the spherical characterisation does not extend unchanged to the torus or projective plane. Keywords: Cycle space; cut space; invariant projection; equivariant map; polyhedral graph; regular polyhedron; orbit counting; chirality; regular map; flag-transitivity; transportation cost space. Mathematics Subject Classification (2020): 05E18 (primary); 05C10, 05C25, 20C15, 52B15, 46B85 (secondary).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dr. Thomas P. Connelly (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: