Why the study?
Can Medicare claims accurately estimate anesthesia and surgical procedure times compared to chart abstraction?
Can Medicare claims accurately estimate anesthesia and surgical procedure times compared to chart abstraction?
Medicare anesthesia claims provide a highly correlated and accurate source for estimating surgery time on a large scale compared to manual chart abstraction.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Medicare claims may accurately estimate procedure times at scale; extends large-database research but requires prospective validation before clinical use.
INTRODUCTION: Procedure length is a fundamental variable associated with quality of care, though seldom studied on a large scale. The authors sought to estimate procedure length through information obtained in the anesthesia claim submitted to Medicare to validate this method for future studies. METHODS: The Obesity and Surgical Outcomes Study enlisted 47 hospitals located across New York, Texas, and Illinois to study patients undergoing hip, knee, colon, and thoracotomy procedures. A total of 15,914 charts were abstracted to determine body mass index and initial patient physiology. Included in this abstraction were induction, cut, close, and recovery room times. This chart information was merged to Medicare claims that included anesthesia Part B billing information. Correlations between chart times and claim times were analyzed, models developed, and median absolute differences in minutes calculated. RESULTS: Of the 15,914 eligible patients, there were 14,369 for whom both chart and claim times were available for analysis. For these 14,369, the Spearman correlation between chart and claim time was 0.94 (95% CI 0.94, 0.95), and the median absolute difference between chart and claim time was only 5 min (95% CI: 5.0, 5.5). The anesthesia claim can also be used to estimate surgical procedure length, with only a modest increase in error. CONCLUSION: The anesthesia bill found in Medicare claims provides an excellent source of information for studying surgery time on a vast scale throughout the United States. However, errors in both chart abstraction and anesthesia claims can occur. Care must be taken in the handling of outliers in these data.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Silber et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: