Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter clarifies that while ECG-guided CVC placement reduces the need for repeat chest X-rays, the decision to eliminate routine initial chest X-rays should be made by a multidisciplinary panel.
In Response: Dr. Farooq raises several issues regarding (1) our investigation of the accuracy of central venous catheter (CVC) placement utilizing ECG guidance (2). First, the cable which is used to connect the guidewire to the ECG adapter is included in each CVC kit and therefore is sterile. The cable itself is equipped with an alligator clip at one end and a plug at the other end. During ECG guidance, the alligator clip is connected to the guidewire by the operator while the other end is dropped to an assistant, e.g., the circulating nurse. The assistant then establishes the connection to the non-sterile ECG adapter by plugging the cable in. Sterility of the CVC itself, the guidewire, and the operator is maintained at all times. Second, our investigation was not designed to evaluate whether the requirements for initial routine chest X-rays (CXR) after CVC placement using ECG guidance can be modified. Consequently, we did not make such a statement. While some earlier investigations (3,4) based on their results have suggested that routine CXRs after CVC placement under ECG control may be eliminated altogether, we only reported a significantly reduced need for repeat CXRs in those patients who had their CVCs placed with ECG guidance. Furthermore, we clearly state in our last paragraph that recommendations regarding completely replacing CXR verification of CVC placement with ECG guidance should be left to a multidisciplinary panel of experts, reviewing all available data and discussing potential benefits and risks. I agree with Dr. Farooq that such risks would include missing serious complications such as a pneumothorax. Ralf E. Gebhard, MD Department of Anesthesiology Ryder Trauma Center, University of Miami-Miller School of Medicine Miami, FL [email protected]
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ralf E. Gebhard (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: