Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors argue that limited pre-operative echocardiography omitting right ventricular, non-aortic valve, and diastolic assessments may miss clinically relevant peri-operative risks.
We read with interest the article by Loxdale et al. on the routine pre-operative use of transthoracic echocardiography in patients with a hip fracture [1], and would like to make some observations. Their technique omits reporting of the right ventricle, non-aortic valves and diastole. Right ventricular dysfunction is a strong and independent predictor of mortality in left ventricular dysfunction, and is associated with increased peri-operative morbidity and mortality in aortic stenosis [2]. In the age range of Loxdale et al.’s study, valvular disease is common and only one third is aortic stenosis [3]. Moderate or severe mitral regurgitation is commonly associated with poor left ventricular function, correlates with postoperative cardiac morbidity [4] and even with a normal left ventricular ejection fraction may lead to impaired contractile reserve [5]. With regard to diastole, half of patients with congestive heart failure have normal systolic function, and half undergoing cardiac or non-cardiac procedures have abnormal diastolic function [6]. Pre-operative asymptomatic ventricular dysfunction is associated with increased 30–day and long-term mortality and morbidity, and diastolic assessment provides incremental prognostic value over systolic assessment [6]. We therefore suggest that clinically relevant peri-operative assessments have been omitted. The authors did not state how left ventricular ejection fraction was assessed nor if the same technique was used by all operators. Four standard methods (Simpson’s biplane, Teicholz, wall-motion scoring and ‘eyeballing’) are poorly interchangeable [7]. The first two do not correlate well with left ventricular ejection fraction in left ventricular hypertrophy [8] and are affected differently by permanent cardiac pacing [9]. Both conditions are prevalent in this patient group. Finally, we wonder why assessment of aortic stenosis was limited to the peak gradient which, as the authors say, can be misleading in low cardiac output states and is recognised as a poor measure of aortic stenosis when used in isolation [10]. Although focused transthoracic echocardiography is widely taught, we must be careful that limiting the breadth of our studies does not broaden our definition of ‘normal’. We are uneasy about the comment that “in the 96 patients where a murmur was heard, 30 (31%) had a normal echocardiogram” given the limited data presented. Although the authors demonstrate pre-operative data (time to theatre, influence on consultations and anaesthetic technique), they report no postoperative data on patient outcome. We consider this the most important marker.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dawes et al. (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: