Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors clarify their findings on the prognostic value of right heart function in elderly hip fracture patients with severe aortic stenosis and discuss the limitations of routine diastolic function assessment in this population.
Thank you for the letters related to our recent article [1]. Right heart function can and does predict mortality in patients with severe aortic stenosis. The paper quoted by Dawes and Alexiou [2] looked at patients who underwent aortic valve repair on the background of severe aortic stenosis and pulmonary hypertension. Pulmonary hypertension may alter the decision to perform an aortic valve replacement, but realistically our hip fracture patients are unlikely to be offered aortic valve replacement before fracture stabilisation, therefore this information will not alter our peri-operative management. In the European survey referred to, the patients were seen in either a medical or surgical cardiology department with a mean age of 64 years [3], compared with our patients whose mean age was 84 years. The survey supports our findings that aortic valve disease is the commonest form of valvular heart disease, with aortic stenosis contributing 33.9%. Interestingly, in this much younger population, intervention such as valve replacement was not carried out for reasons including old age, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, renal failure and short life expectancy. We do not have the luxury to cancel operations because of these common co-morbidities and this is not the same surgical population. We performed our study in 2007–08 at a time when the relevance of diastolic dysfunction was unclear; indeed, research on this topic has only recently been published [4]. There appears to be an increasing body of evidence that assessment of diastolic function may be important, but most of the studies report patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting or major vascular surgery [4]. Evaluation of diastolic function requires a comprehensive grading algorithm for a transthoracic echocardiography examination, and no single Doppler index is able to make the diagnosis with absolute certainty. In the absence of any specific therapy to improve diastolic function, the impact of routine assessment on postoperative outcome is unclear. At present, this information will add little to our choice of anaesthetic technique, but it may help improve management in the future. All our examinations were carried out by senior echocardiography technicians (British Society of Echocardiography accredited), who all used a similar method of visual left ventricular ejection fraction estimation. The European Association and the British Society of Echocardiography now recommend an integrated approach to the grading of severity of aortic stenosis. The European and American Societies of Echocardiography produced guidelines for the assessment of valvular heart disease in 2009, due to widespread inconsistencies in measurement across Europe and America. Mean transaortic gradient may be more representative of aortic stenosis than peak gradient but there is good correlation between these measurements. We may need to change our measurements to enhance the certainty of the grading of the severity. We agree with the comment about our poor choice of the words ‘normal echocardiogram’ when we referred to a focused transthoracic echocardiogram, but we meant normal with reference to the aortic valve and systolic ventricular function. Patient outcome is an important marker, and we did not comment on this in the article. At that time, 30-day patient mortality data in our hospital were not fully available. The situation is now completely different, and these data could easily be collected and interpreted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Loxdale et al. (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: